Kiểm định hiệu lực ngang giá sức mua PPP giữa Việt Nam với Thái Lan và Malaysia

27ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ .,ӆ0Ĉӎ1++,ӊ8/Ӵ&1*$1**,ẩ6Ӭ&08$333 *,Ӳ$9,ӊ71$09Ӟ,7+ẩ,/$19ơ0$/$<6,$ 7+(385&+$6,1*32:(53$5,7<$021*9,(71$07+$,/$1'$1'0$- /$<6,$ +͛7Kͯ\7LrQ1+͛7KX+RjL11J{9ăQ7RjQ1 1Jj\QKұQ  1Jj\QKұQEҧQVӱD1Jj\ÿăQJ 7yPWҳW %jLEiRWLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKKLӋXOӵFQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYӟL7KiL/DQYj0D- OD\VLD9ӟLFiFKWLӃSFұQFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLYjFKӍVӕJLiOjSKLWX\ӃQYjVӱGөQJP{KuQKKӗLTX\ EiQWKDPVӕFK~QJW{LÿmWuPWKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYj7KiL/DQQKѭQJNK{QJWuP WKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLD.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭXFKRWKҩ\FKtQKViFKWӹJLiҧQK KѭӣQJUҩWOӟQYjRVӵWӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYӟL7KiL/DQYj0DOD\VLD.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭX cũn SKiWKLӋQPӝWÿLӇPTXDQWUӑQJÿyQJJySWKrPYjROờWKX\ӃW333ÿyOjW͛QW̩LKD\NK{QJW͛QW̩L333 NK{QJFK͑FͱQJQK̷F[HP[pWÿ͡O͏FKFͯDP͡WÿL͋PVRYͣLÿ˱ͥQJ333PjWK{QJWK˱ͥQJFyÿ͡O͏FK WURQJP͡WSK̩PYLQK̭Wÿ͓QKVRYͣLÿ˱ͥQJ333ÿ͋OờJL̫LFKRFiFFKLSKtWURQJJLDRG͓FKWK˱˯QJP̩L TX͙FW͇YjFiF\͇XW͙NKiFWiFÿ͡QJ.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭXFKRWKҩ\SKҥPYLQj\Oj1ӃXÿӝOӋFKUD NKӓLÿѭӡQJ333QKӓKѫQWKuYүQÿѭӧF[HPOjWӗQWҥLQJDQJJLiVӭFPXDWUѭӡQJKӧS9LӋW1DP Yj7KiL/DQQӃXÿӝOӋFKYѭӧWTXiWKuNӃWOXұQOjNK{QJWӗQWҥLQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD333WUѭӡQJ KӧS9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLD 7ӯNKyDKLӋXOӵFQJDQJJLiVӭFPXDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLFKӍVӕJLiSKLWX\ӃQKӗLTX\EiQWKDPVӕ $EVWUDFW 7KHSDSHUH[DPLQHVWKHSXUFKDVLQJSRZHUSDULW\333DPRQJ9LHWQDP7KDLODQGDQG0DOD\VLD:LWK WKHDSSURDFKXVLQJWKHH[FKDQJHUDWHVHULHVDQGWKHQRQOLQHDUSULFHLQGH[DQGXVLQJWKHVHPLSDUDPHW- ULFUHJUHVVLRQPRGHOZHKDYHIRXQGWKHH[LVWHQFHRI333VEHWZHHQ9LHWQDPDQG7KDLODQGEXWIRXQG QRH[LVWHQFHDW333EHWZHHQ9LHWQDPDQG0DOD\VLD7KHUHVXOWVRIWKHVWXG\VKRZWKDWH[FKDQJHUDWH SROLF\KDVDJUHDWLQÀXHQFHRQWKHH[LVWHQFHRI333VDPRQJ9LHWQDP7KDLODQGDQG0DOD\VLD7KH ¿QGLQJVDOVRUHYHDODQLPSRUWDQWSRLQWFRQWULEXWLQJWRWKH333WKHRU\WKDWH[LVWVRUGRHVQRWH[LVW PPP is not only rigidly considering the deviation of one point compared to the PPP curve but there is usually a deviation in a certain range of PPP lines to account for costs in international trade transac- WLRQVDQGRWKHUIDFWRUVLPSDFW5HVHDUFKVKRZVWKDWWKLVUDQJHLV,IWKHGHYLDWLRQRXWRIWKH333LV OHVVWKDQLWLVVWLOOFRQVLGHUHG333LQWKHFDVHRI9LHWQDPDQG7KDLODQGLIWKHGHYLDWLRQH[FHHGV WKHFRQFOXVLRQLVWKDW333GRHVQRWH[LVWLQWKHFDVHRI9LHWQDPDQG0DOD\VLD .H\ZRUGVSXUFKDVLQJSRZHUSDULW\H[FKDQJH UDWHVHULHVQRQOLQHDUSULFH LQGH[ VHPLSDUDPHWULF regression model 1 Trường Đại học Tài chớnh – Marketing *LӟLWKLӋX /ҥPSKiWYjWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLFyTXDQKӋYӟL QKDX WK{QJTXD Oờ WKX\ӃW1JDQJJLiVӭFPXD 7KHR Oờ WKX\ӃW Qj\ JLi Fҧ FӫD FQJPӝW ORҥL KjQJKyDOjJLӕQJQKDXFKRGEiQӣEҩWNǤTXӕF JLDQjR1ӃXFyPӝWVӵFKrQKOӋFKWURQJJLiFҧ KjQJKyDJLӳDTXӕFJLDWKuNLQKGRDQKFKrQK OӋFKJLiVӁ[ҧ\UDKӋTXҧOjWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLVӁ ÿLӅXFKӍQKÿӇOjPFkQEҵQJPӭFJLiKjQJKyD .ӇWӯNKLOờWKX\ӃWQj\ÿѭӧFSKiWELӇXYjRQăP 37ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ EӣLQKjNLQKWӃKӑF*XVWDY&DVVHOÿmFy UҩWQKLӅXFiFQJKLrQFӭXWKӵFKLӋQÿӇNLӇPÿӏQK OờWKX\ӃWQj\WURQJWKӵFWӃ&iFQJKLrQFӭXFKR ÿӃQQD\FKLDUDOjPWUѭӡQJSKiL7UѭӡQJSKiL ÿҫXWLrQNKҷQJÿӏQKWӗQWҥLQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD YjWUѭӡQJSKiLFzQOҥLWKuNK{QJ.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQ FӭXFyFKtQK[iFKD\NK{QJSKөWKXӝFUҩWOӟQ YjRSKѭѫQJSKiSVӱGөQJYjTXDQÿLӇPYӅPӕL TXDQKӋJLӳDFKXӛLGӳOLӋXOҥPSKiWYjWӹJLi KӕLÿRiL%jLEiRQj\ӫQJKӝTXDQÿLӇPTXDQ KӋSKLWX\ӃQJLӳDFKXӛLGӳOLӋXWUrQ9uYұ\ P{KuQKYjSKѭѫQJSKiSQJKLrQFӭX VӁ WKLrQ YӅTXDQÿLӇPQj\NKLNLӇPÿӏQKFyKD\NK{QJ WӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYjÿӕLWiFFyJLDR GӏFKWKѭѫQJPҥLOӟQQKҩWWURQJ$6($1Oj7KiL /DQYj0DOD\VLDWURQJJLDLÿRҥQQJKLrQFӭXWӯ WKiQJÿӃQWKiQJ 7әQJTXDQFiFQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟFÿk\ 1KuQ FKXQJ FiF FKXӛL WKӡL JLDQ trong kinh WӃWKѭӡQJÿѭӧFFKROjSKLWX\ӃQ7RQJ (QJOH  %ROOHUVOHY  Yj FiF QKj NLQK WӃ WKѭӡQJ [k\ GӵQJ WtQK SKL WX\ӃQ Qj\ WKHRPӝW WURQJKDLFiFKVDX L[k\GӵQJP{ KuQK SKL WX\ӃQ ÿӝQJ FKRPӝW FKXӛL WKӡL JLDQ Fө WKӇ +DQQDQ  )DQ DQG<DR  *DRKRһFLL[HP[pWPӕLTXDQKӋSKL WX\ӃQJLӳDKDLFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQ*UDQJHU &KHQ&iFEjLQJKLrQFӭXYӅVӵWӗQWҥL FӫD 333 ÿѭӧF WKӵF KLӋQ WUrQ QKLӅX TXӕF JLD YjWѭѫQJӭQJYӟLKDLFiFK[k\GӵQJWUrQWKuFy KDL KѭӟQJ ÿӇ NLӇP ÿӏQK ÿy Oj  NLӇP ÿӏQK QJKLӋPÿѫQYӏFӫDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLWKӵFYj NLӇPÿӏQKWtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWWURQJPӕLTXDQ KӋJLӳDWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLGDQKQJKƭDYjFKӍVӕJLi WLrXGQJJLӳDKDLTXӕFJLDFҫQNLӇPÿӏQK&iF SKѭѫQJSKiSNLӇPÿӏQKQJKLӋPÿѫQYӏYjÿӗQJ OLrQNӃW WUX\ӅQWKӕQJOjSKѭѫQJSKiSÿѭӧFVӱ GөQJUӝQJUmLWURQJFiFQJKLrQFӭXWKӵFQJKLӋP FӫD333 QKѭQJ FiFSKѭѫQJSKiSQj\ WKѭӡQJ NK{QJ WuP WKҩ\ EҵQJ FKӭQJ FKR WKҩ\ Vӵ WӗQ WҥL FӫD3331KӳQJ WKҩWEҥLQj\GүQÿӃQYLӋF VӱGөQJQKLӅXSKѭѫQJSKiSPӟLÿӇ WuPNLӃP EҵQJFKӭQJYӅ333EDRJӗPVӱGөQJEӝGӳOLӋX YӟLWKӡLJLDQGjLKѫQ7D\ORUVӱGөQJ SKѭѫQJ SKiS NLӇP ÿӏQK QJKLӋP ÿѫQ Yӏ GҥQJ EҧQJ7D\ORUYjVӱGөQJFiFP{KuQK SKLWX\ӃQ+DLSKѭѫQJSKiSÿҫXWLrQOLrQTXDQ ÿӃQYLӋFVӱGөQJFiFEӝGӳOLӋXNKiFQKDXÿӇ FҧLWKLӋQYLӋFNLӇPWUD333WX\QKLrQFyQKѭӧF ÿLӇPOjEӓTXDVӵSKөWKXӝFFӫDFiFTXӕFJLD 2ả&RQQHOO7URQJNKLÿySKѭѫQJSKiS VӱGөQJP{KuQKSKLWX\ӃQFyWtQKÿӃQFiF\ӃX WӕNLQKWӃNKiFFyWiFÿӝQJÿӃQWӹJLiKӕLÿRiL FKLSKtJLDRGӏFKYҩQÿӅVWLFN\SULFHVӁFKR NӃWTXҧÿiQJWLQFұ\KѫQ ộ WѭӣQJ YӅ P{ KuQK Wӹ JLi KӕL ÿRiL SKL WX\ӃQ ÿҫX WLrQ ÿѭӧF SKiW KLӋQ EӣL+HFNVFKHU éQJFKR UҵQJFKtQKFKLSKtJLDRGӏFK TXӕF WӃ JLӳD WKӏ WUѭӡQJ KDL TXӕF JLD GR NKiF ELӋWYӅNK{QJJLDQOjQJX\rQQKkQGүQÿӃQVӵ SKLWX\ӃQ6DXÿyPӝWORҥWFiFQJKLrQFӭXWKӵF QJKLӋPÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQQKҵPSKiWWULӇQP{KuQK Oờ WKX\ӃWYӅ WӹJLi WKӵFSKL WX\ӃQYj VӱGөQJ FiFP{ KuQK Qj\ ÿӇ NLӇP WUD JLҧ WKX\ӃW 333 %DXP HW DO 2ả&RQQHOO DQG:HL ÿm NӃ WKӯD QJKLrQ FӭX FӫD+HFNVFKHU  [HP[pWP{KuQKWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLSKLWX\ӃQGѭӟL JyFÿӝFKLSKtJLDRGӏFK1JRjLUDYӟLJLҧÿӏQK FiFF{QJW\FyVӵSKkQELӋWJLiӣFiFTXӕFJLD NKiFQKDXQJKLrQFӭXFӫD&DUYDOKRYj1HFKLR FKRWKҩ\YҩQÿӅVWLFN\±SULFHOjQJX\rQ QKkQ OjPFKR WKӏ WUѭӡQJKjQJKyD ÿLӅX FKӍQK FKұPKѫQWKӏWUѭӡQJWjLVҧQNKLFyF~VӕF[ҧ\UD ĈLӅXQj\QJөờPӕLTXDQKӋSKLWX\ӃQJLӳDWӹ JLiKӕLÿRiLYjFKӍVӕJLiFӫDQӅQNLQKWӃ7KrP YjRÿyYҩQÿӅOӧLWKӃQăQJVXҩWWѭѫQJÿӕLJLӳD FiF TXӕFJLD FNJQJ OjPӝW WURQJQKӳQJ\ӃX Wӕ ӫQJKӝFKRP{KuQK WӹJLiKӕLÿRiLSKL WX\ӃQ &KRQJHWDO 9ӟL FiFK WLӃS FұQ ÿҫX WLrQ PӝW Vӕ QKj QJKLrQFӭXWLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKQJKLӋPÿѫQYӏ WUrQ FKXӛL Wӹ JLi KӕL ÿRiL WKӵF0LFKDHO HW DO VӱGөQJGӳOLӋXKjQJWKiQJFӫDEӕQTXӕF JLD0ӻ$QK3KiSYjĈӭFÿӇP{WҧTXiWUuQK ÿLӅXFKӍQKSKLWX\ӃQVӱGөQJ6PRRWK7UDQVLWLRQ $XWRUHJUHVVLYH 0RGHO YӟL WӕF ÿӝ ÿLӅX FKӍQK WKD\ ÿәL+ӑ WKҩ\ UҵQJ QӃX GӵD WUrQP{ KuQK WX\ӃQWtQKNKҧQăQJEiFEӓVӵWәQWҥLFӫD333 UҩWFDRPһFGWURQJGjLKҥQYүQFyVӵWӗQWҥL FӫD333&iFWiFJLҧWuPWKҩ\FKXӛLWӹJLiKӕL ÿRiL WKӵF Fy[XKѭӟQJKӝL Wө YӅ JLi WUӏ WUXQJ EuQK+D\QyLFiFKNKiFFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiL WKӵFOjFKXӛLGӯQJFKRWKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333 %DXPYjFӝQJVӵVӱGөQJGӳOLӋXWURQJ WKӡLNǤKұX%UHWWRQ:RRGVYjVӱGөQJ6PRRWK 7UDQVLWLRQ$XWRUHJUHVVLYH0RGHOÿmPӝWOҫQQӳD 47ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ NKҷQJ ÿӏQK NӃW TXҧ FӫD0LFKDHO HW DO  7LӃSÿyEjLQJKLrQFӭXFӫD%DKPDQL2VNRRHH WKD\YuVӱGөQJNLӇPÿӏQK$')FKXҭQ Kӑ Vӱ GөQJ NLӇPÿӏQKPӟL NӃW KӧS SKL WX\ӃQ WURQJ FKXӛL Wӹ JLi WKӵF FӫDTXӕFJLD F{QJ QJKLӋS .ӃW TXҧ FKR WKҩ\ SKѭѫQJ SKiS NLӇP ÿӏQKPӟLӫQJKӝVӵ WӗQ WҥL333ӣQKLӅXTXӕF JLDKѫQSKѭѫQJSKiS$')WK{QJWKѭӡQJ*ҫQ ÿk\*LUDLWLVYjFӝQJVӵÿӅ[XҩWVӱGөQJ FiFP{KuQKKӋVӕELӃQÿәLWKHRWKӡLJLDQQJүX QKLrQÿӇNLӇPWUDJLҧWKX\ӃW333+ӑVӱGөQJGӳ OLӋXWӹJLiWKӵFÿӇSKKӧSYӟLP{KuQKWӵKӗL TX\YjWұSWUXQJYjRYLӋFSKkQWtFKVӵKӝLWөYӅ JLiWUӏWUXQJEuQKFӫDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLWKӵF .ӃWTXҧFKRWKҩ\VӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333 9ӟL FiFK WLӃS FұQ WKӭ KDL FiF QKj QJKLrQ FӭXWLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKWtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWJLӳD FKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLGDQKQJKƭDYjFKXӛLFKӍVӕ JLi7UѭӟFÿk\FiFNLӇPÿӏQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWFKӫ \ӃXÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQӣGҥQJÿӗQJOLrQNӃWWX\ӃQ WtQK WX\ QKLrQ NLӇP ÿӏQK WX\ӃQ WtQK WKѭӡQJ WKҩWEҥLNKLWuPUDPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFiFFKXӛL WKӡLJLDQNK{QJGӯQJQӃXFK~QJFyPӕLTXDQ KӋSKLWX\ӃQ*UDQJHU+RQJYj3KLOOLSV OұSOXұQUҵQJFiFFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQNK{QJ GӯQJFyNKX\QKKѭӟQJOjFiFFKXӛLFyEѭӟFÿL QJүXQKLrQUDQGRPZDONFKRQrQQӃXVӱGөQJ FiFѭӟF OѭӧQJ WX\ӃQ WtQKFKRFiFNӃWKӧSSKL WX\ӃQFyWKӇGүQÿӃQNӃWTXҧVDLOӋFKWURQJGjL KҥQ'RÿyFiFWiFJLҧQj\WKӵFKLӋQNLӇPÿӏQK 5HJUHVVLRQ (UURU 6SHFL¿FDWLRQ 7HVW 5(6(7 VӱGөQJFKXӛLGӳOLӋXWKӡLJLDQNK{QJGӯQJÿӇ NLӇPÿӏQKWUӵFWLӃSFKRPӕLTXDQKӋÿӗQJOLrQ NӃWWX\ӃQWtQKYjKӑWuQKWKҩ\UҩWtWEҵQJFKӭQJ ӫQJKӝVӵSKKӧSFӫDÿһF WtQKÿӗQJ OLrQNӃW WX\ӃQWtQK1KѭYұ\YӟLFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQNK{QJ GӯQJYjSKLWX\ӃQVӱGөQJFiFKNӃWKӧSWX\ӃQ WtQKVӁGүQÿӃQNӃWTXҧVDLOӋFK&iFQJKLrQFӭX VDXQj\ WұS WUXQJVӱGөQJP{KuQKSKL WX\ӃQ ÿӇ [HP [pW Vӵ WӗQ WҥL FӫD 333 ÿLӇQ KuQK EjL QJKLrQFӭXFӫD/L/LQYj+VLDRVӱGөQJ P{KuQKEiQWKDPVӕYӟLKӋVӕKӗLTX\WKD\ÿәL QKҵPNLӇPÿӏQKVӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333JLӳD0ӻ $QK0ӻ 1KұWYj0ӻ &DQDGD%jLQJKLrQ FӭX Qj\ WKӵF KLӋQ ÿӗQJ WKӡL Fҧ SKѭѫQJ SKiS WUX\ӅQWKӕQJYjSKѭѫQJSKiSPӟLKӑWKҩ\UҵQJ NKLVӱGөQJSKѭѫQJSKiSEiQWKDPVӕNӃWTXҧ ӫQJKӝVӵWӗQWҥLFӫD333FyӣFҧEDFһSTXӕF gia. 'R ÿy YӟL FiF FKXӛL Wӹ JLi KӕL ÿRiL GDQK QJKƭDYjFKXӛLFKӍVӕJLiNK{QJGӯQJNKLNLӇP ÿӏQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWWURQJPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFiF FKXӛL Qj\ Vӱ GөQJP{ KuQK SKL WX\ӃQ VӁ SK KӧSYjFKRNӃWTXҧFKtQK[iFKѫQ%jLEiRQj\ QKyPWiFJLҧNӃWKӯDP{KuQKEiQWKDPVӕYӟL KӋVӕKӗLTX\WKD\ÿәLFӫD;LDRÿӇWLӃQ KjQK NLӇP ÿӏQK Vӵ WӗQ WҥL FӫD 333 JLӳD9LӋW 1DP±7KiL/DQYj9LӋW1DP±0DOD\VLD 3KѭѫQJSKiSQJKLrQFӭX 'ӳOLӋXWURQJQJKLrQFӭXQj\ÿѭӧFQKyPWiF JLҧWKXWKұSWKHRWKiQJYӅWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLGDQK QJKƭDFӫD91'7+%0<5YӟL86'FKӍVӕ JLiWLrXGQJ&3,FӫD9LӋW1DP7KiL/DQYj 0DOD\VLD WURQJJLDLÿRҥQ WӯQăPÿӃQ QăP1JXӗQGӳOLӋXÿѭӧFOҩ\Wӯ4Xӻ 7LӅQWӋTXӕFWӃ,QWHUQDWLRQDO0RQHWDU\)XQG± ,0)Yj7KRPVRQ5HXWHU %jLEiRVӱGөQJP{KuQKEiQWKDPVӕYӟLKӋ VӕKӗLTX\WKD\ÿәLQKѭVDX ࢙࢚ = ࢼ૙(ࢠ࢚) + ࢼ૚(ࢠ࢚)࢖࢚ + ࢼ૚(ࢠ࢚)࢖࢚כ + ࣆ࢚   7URQJÿy stWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLGDQKQJKƭDJLӳD9LӋW 1DP Yj TXӕF JLD L L OҫQ OѭӧW Oj 7KiL /DQ 0DOD\VLD pt FKӍ Vӕ JLi WLrX GQJ FӫD9LӋW 1DP 9,( p*tFKӍVӕJLiWLrXGQJOҫQOѭӧWFӫD7KiL /DQ7+$0DOD\VLD0$/ ztOjELӃQVӕFӕÿӏQKҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQPӕL TXDQKӋJLӳDVt, ptYjS t7URQJEjLQJKLrQFӭX Qj\QKyPWiFJLҧOӵDFKӑQ]tOjFKrQKOӋFKOmL VXҩWJLӳDKDLTXӕFJLDPөFWLrXEӣLYuPӕLTXDQ KӋJLӳDPӭFJLiYjWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLVRQJSKѭѫQJ WKѭӡQJ Eӏ ҧQK KѭӣQJ EӣL FKrQK OӋFK OmL VXҩW JLӳDKDLTXӕFJLDĈӇWtQKFKӍVӕ]tEjLQJKLrQ FӭXWKXWKұSGӳOLӋXOmLVXҩWWtQSKLӃXNKREҥF NǤKҥQWKiQJYjOmLVXҩWWUiLSKLӃXNKREҥFNǤ KҥQQăP]tÿѭӧFWtQKQKѭVDX (1) 57ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ %LӃQ 0{Wҧ &iFKWtQK st 7ӹJLiKӕLÿRiLJLӳD7+%91'Yj0<5 91' pt &3,FӫD9LӋW1DP OQ&3,91' p*t &3,FӫDQѭӟFFzQOҥL OQ&3,7+%0<5 zt &KӋQKOӋFKOmLVXҩWJLӳDKDLFһSTXӕFJLD 7\WL±73m,t,i±7\W91'±7PW91' zt 7\WL±73m,t,i±7\W91'±7PW91' YӟLL 7+%0<5 1KyPWiFJLҧWұSWUXQJYjRNLӇPÿӏQKÿӗQJ OLrQNӃWFӫDP{KuQKÿӇNLӇPÿӏQKJLҧWKX\ӃW PPP. .ờKLӋX ݔݐ = (1,݌ݐ ,݌ݐכ)ܶ ,ߚ(ݖ) = (ߚ0(ݖ),ߚ1(ݖ),ߚ2(ݖ))ܶ 0{KuQKÿѭӧFYLӃWOҥLQKѭVDX ࢙࢚ = ࢚࢞Ԣ ࢼ(ࢠ) + ࢛࢚ &iFKӋVӕKӗLTX\WURQJP{KuQKÿѭӧFWtQK QKѭVDX ߚመݐ(ݖ) = ൥෍ݔݐݔݐܶܭ݄(ݖݐ െ ݖ) ܶ ݐ=1 ൩ െ1 ෍ݔݐݏݐܭ݄(ݖݐ െ ݖ) ܶ ݐ=1 9ӟL ܭ݄(ݖݐ െ ݖ) = ݄െ1ܭ ቀ ݖݐ െ ݖ ݄ ቁ .OjKjP.HUQHOYjKOjWKDPVӕEDQGZLGWK 1KyPWiFJLҧVӱGөQJѭӟFOѭӧQJ*DXVVLDQNHU- QHOYjFKӑQEDQGZLGWKWӕLѭXEҵQJFiFKVӱGөQJ SKѭѫQJSKiS/6&9/HDVW6TXDUH&URVV9DOL- GDWLRQPHWKRG ĈӇ NLӇP ÿӏQK ÿӗQJ OLrQ NӃW QKyP WiF JLҧ WLӃQKjQKJLӳ OҥLSKҫQGѭFӫDP{KuQK Yj WKӵFKLӋQNLӇPÿӏQKWKHRSKѭѫQJSKiSFӫD;LDR %jLEiRWLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKKӋVӕ]HUR FӫDELӃQ[XKѭӟQJWKӡLJLDQWURQJP{KuQK ࢛ෝ࢚૛ = ࢇ+ ࢈࢚+ ࢋ࢚ *L̫WKX\͇W+0:0{KuQKNK{QJFy[XKѭӟQJ WKӡL JLDQ WӭF Oj FKXӛL Xt Oj FKXӛL GӯQJ WUXQJ EuQK+D\QyLFiFKNKiFFyPӕLTXDQKӋÿӗQJ OLrQNӃWJLӳDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLYjFKXӛLJLi 1KѭYұ\ӫQJKӝJLҧWKX\ӃW333 %jLEiRÿѭӧFWLӃQKjQKWKHRWUuQKWӵQKѭVDX - .LӇP ÿӏQK QJKLӋP ÿѫQ Yӏ EҵQJ$') ')*/6Yj33ÿӕLYӟLFiFFKXӛLWӹJLi KӕL ÿRiL FKXӛL &3, Yj FKXӛL ]t 9ӟL FKXӛL Wӹ JLi KӕL ÿRiL Yj &3, QӃX FiF FKXӛLQj\NK{QJGӯQJYjOj,NKLÿy YLӋFiSGөQJP{KuQKEiQ WKDPVӕ WKӇ KLӋQPӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLYj FKӍVӕJLiOjSKKӧS+RQJYj3KLOOLSV 9ӟLFKXӛL]tWKHR;LDR ÿk\SKҧLOjFKXӛLGӯQJ - +ӗL TX\P{ KuQK  Vӱ GөQJ SKѭѫQJ SKiS/6&9/HDVWVTXDUHFURVV±YDO- LGDWLRQFӫD6XQYj/LÿӇWuPUD WKDPVӕEDQGZLGWKWӕLѭX - .ӃWKӯDSKѭѫQJSKiSFӫD;LDR NLӇPÿӏQKVӵWӗQWҥLFӫDOờWKX\ӃWQJDQJ (2) (3) %ҧQJ%LӃQQJKLrQFӭX 67ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ %ҧQJ%DQGZLGWKWӕLѭXFKRFiFFһSTXӕFJLD &һSTXӕFJLD 9,(7+$ 9,(0$/ Bandwidth   JLiVӭFPXDEҵQJP{KuQKKӗLTX\EiQ WKDPVӕFyWKDPVӕWKD\ÿәLEҵQJFiFK NLӇPWUDWtQKGӯQJFӫDSKҫQGѭ .ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭX ĈӇNLӇPÿӏQKFyWӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DP YjTXӕFJLDFzQOҥLQKyPWiFJLҧWLӃQKjQKFiF NLӇPÿӏQKQKҵPWuPUDWtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWJLӳDWӹ JLiKӕLÿRiLYj&3,FӫDFiFFһSTXӕFJLD ĈҫXWLrQQKyPWiFJLҧWKӵFKLӋQNLӇPÿӏQK WtQKGӯQJFӫDFiFFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQVӱGөQJWURQJ EjL QJKLrQ FӭX EDR JӗP FiF FKXӛL YӅ Wӹ JLi KӕLÿRiLYjFKXӛLFKӍVӕ&3,/ҫQOѭӧWVӱGөQJ SKѭѫQJ SKiS $') ')*/6 Yj 33 NӃW TXҧ ÿѭӧFWKӇKLӋQӣ%ҧQJ %ҧQJ.LӇPÿӏQKWtQKGӯQJFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕLÿRiLYj&3, %LӃQ $') ')*/6 33, , , , , , PVIE       S7+%91'       PTHA       S0<591'       P0$/         9ӟL JLҧ WKX\ӃW + FiF FKXӛL WKӡL JLDQ Fy QJKLӋPÿѫQYӏ.ӃWTXҧӣFiFFӝW,ӣFҧED NLӇP ÿӏQK ÿӅX FKҩS QKұQ JLҧ WKX\ӃW +, hay QyLFiFKNKiFFiFFKXӛLQj\ÿӅXNK{QJGӯQJ 1KyP WiF JLҧ WLӃQ KjQK Oҩ\ VDL SKkQ FӫD FiF FKXӛLWKӡLJLDQYjWKӵFKLӋQOҥLFiFNLӇPÿӏQK NӃWTXҧFiFFӝW,FKRWKҩ\FiFFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQ Qj\ÿӅXGӯQJ1KѭYұ\FiFFKXӛLWKӡLJLDQWӹ JLiYjFKӍVӕ&3,OjFiFFKXӛLEұFQKҩWa, 1Kѭ Yұ\ YLӋF Vӱ GөQJP{ KuQK KӗL TX\ EiQ WKDPVӕYӟLKӋVӕKӗLTX\WKD\ÿәLOjSKKӧS +RQJYj3KLOOLSV 7KHR&DL HW DO  Yj;LDR  FKӍ Vӕ]tÿҥLGLӋQEӣLFKrQK OӋFK OmLVXҩWJLӳDFiFFһSTXӕFJLDYjSKҧLGӯQJ'RÿyQKyPWiFJLҧ WLӃQKjQKNLӇPÿӏQKWtQKGӯQJFӫDFKXӛL]tEҵQJNLӇPÿӏQK$')Yj33.ӃWTXҧ WKӇKLӋQ WURQJ %ҧQJ %ҧQJ.LӇPÿӏQKWtQKGӯQJFKXӛL]WVӱGөQJNLӇPÿӏQK$')Yj33 %LӃQ $') 33 ZTHA-VIE   Z0$/9,(   9ӟLJLҧWKX\ӃW+FiFFKXӛL]tFyQJKLӋPÿѫQ YӏVӱGөQJNLӇPÿӏQK$')Yj33ÿӅXEiFEӓJLҧ WKX\ӃW+ӣPӭFờQJKƭDYjĈLӅX Qj\ FKR WKҩ\ FiF FKXӛL ]t ÿӅX Oj FKXӛL GӯQJ a,.ӃWTXҧQj\WKӓDÿLӅXNLӋQEDQÿҫXFӫD P{KuQK 0ӝWWURQJQKӳQJQJKӋWKXұWNKLVӱGөQJP{ KuQKEiQ WKDPVӕ OjSKҧL FKӑQ WKDPVӕEDQG- ZLGWKSKKӧS7LӃSWKHRQKyPWiFJLҧVӱGөQJ SKѭѫQJSKiS/6&9/HDVWVTXDUHFURVV±YDO- LGDWLRQFӫD6XQYj/LÿӇWuPUDWKDPVӕ EDQGZLGWKWӕLѭX   %ѭӟFFXӕL FQJQKyPQJKLrQFӭXNӃ WKӯD SKѭѫQJSKiSFӫD;LDRNLӇPÿӏQKVӵWӗQ WҥL FӫD Oờ WKX\ӃWQJDQJJLi VӭFPXDEҵQJP{ KuQKKӗLTX\EiQWKDPVӕFyKӋVӕWKD\ÿәLEҵQJ 77ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ %ҧQJĈӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD333 1ăP 7+$91 0$/91 1ăP 7+$91 0$/91                                                 %4   %4   %4   FiFKNLӇPWUDWtQKGӯQJFӫDSKҫQGѭ %ҧQJ.LӇPÿӏQKSKҫQGѭ &һSTXӕFJLD 9,(7+$ 9,(0$/ p-value   9ӟLFһSTXӕFJLD9LӋW1DP±7KiL/DQKӋVӕ SYDOXH OҫQ OѭӧW Oj.ӃWTXҧQj\ÿm WKҩW EҥLWURQJYLӋFEiFEӓJLҧWKX\ӃW+WӭFOjEuQK SKѭѫQJSKҫQGѭNK{QJELӃQÿәLWKHRWKӡLJLDQ +D\QyLFiFKNKiFFKXӛLXtOjFKXӛLGӯQJWUXQJ EuQK'RÿyӣFһSTXӕFJLDQj\QKyPWiFJLҧ WuPWKҩ\WtQKÿӗQJOLrQNӃWJLӳDFKXӛLWӹJLiKӕL ÿRiLYjFKXӛLJLi1KѭYұ\ӫQJKӝJLҧ WKX\ӃW PPP.7X\QKLrQÿӕLYӟLFһSTXӕFJLD9LӋW1DP Yj0DOD\VLDNӃWTXҧOҥLQJѭӧFOҥL9ӟLSYDOXH  ÿmFKRWKҩ\VӵELӃQÿәLWKHRWKӡLJLDQFӫD SKҫQGѭWӭFXtNK{QJGӯQJĈLӅXQj\FKRWKҩ\ OờWKX\ӃWQJDQJJLiVӭFPXDNK{QJÿѭӧFGX\WUu JLӳDFһSTXӕFJLDQj\ ;iFÿӏQKÿӝOӋFKNKӓLÿѭӡQJQJDQJJLiVӭF PXD333 7ӯVӕOLӋXYӅWӹJLiYjOҥPSKiWFӫDWӯQJTXӕF JLD WURQJPүXQJKLrQFӭXQKyP WiFJLҧQKұQ WKҩ\FyVӵFKrQKOӋFKWURQJWKD\ÿәLOҥPSKiW JLӳDTXӕFJLD YӟL WKD\ÿәL Wӹ JLi ÿӗQJ WLӅQ JLӳDTXӕFJLDĈLӅXQj\FKRWKҩ\VӁFyPӝWÿӝ OӋFKFӫDFiFÿLӇPWKӇKLӋQTXDQKӋWURQJWKD\ ÿәLOҥPSKiWYjWӹJLiVRYӟLÿѭӡQJQJDQJJLi VӭFPXDĈӇ[iFÿӏQKÿӝOӋFKQj\QKyPWiFJLҧ VӱGөQJSKѭѫQJSKiSÿӗ WKӏNӃWKӧSYӟLYLӋF [iFÿӏQKNKRҧQJFiFKFӫDWӯQJÿLӇPÿӃQÿѭӡQJ PPP. 9ӟLÿѭӡQJ333YjÿLӇP0[;y .KRҧQJFiFKWӯÿLӇP0ÿӃQÿѭӡQJ333ÿѭӧF WtQKEҵQJF{QJWKӭFVDX ݀(ܯ݋ ,ܲܲܲ) = |ܽݔ0 + ܾݕ0 + ܿ| ξܽ2 + ܾ2 DOjKӋVӕFӫD[YjEOjKӋVӕFӫD\WURQJSKѭѫQJ WUuQK333 87ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ 7KHRNӃWTXҧWtQKÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLQJDQJJLi VӭFPXD333WDWKҩ\WURQJFҧJLDLÿRҥQQJKLrQ FӭXTXӕFJLD0DOD\VLDFyÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ 333OjOӟQQKҩWYӟLÿӝOӋFKOjWURQJNKL 7KiL/DQFyÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLQJDQJJLiVӭFPXD QKӓKѫQ1KuQYjRÿӗ WKӏ FiFÿLӇPSKkQ WiQWұSWUXQJErQWUiLÿѭӡQJ333FKӭQJWӓOҥP SKiW FӫD9LӋW1DP FDR KѫQ QKLӅX VR YӟL OҥP SKiW FӫD0DOD\VLD QKѭQJ ÿLӅX FKӍQK WURQJ Wӹ JLi0<591'NK{QJÿiQJNӇĈk\OjQJX\rQ QKkQ FKӫ \ӃX GҭQ ÿӃQ ÿӝ OӋFK UD NKӓL ÿѭӡQJ 333 FӫD0DOD\VLD FDR WURQJJLDL ÿRҥQQJKLrQ FӭX7ӯEҧQJ WtQKÿӝ OӋFK UDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ333 QKyPWiFJLҧFNJQJFyQKұQÿӏQKPһFGNӃWTXҧ NLӇPÿӏQKFKRWKҩ\WӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DP Yj7KiL/DQQKѭQJÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ333 FӫDTXӕFJLDQj\QKӓKѫQ9ұ\FyWKӇNӃW OXұQ YQJ WӗQ WҥL333NK{QJ FKӍ Oj QҵP WUrQ ÿѭӡQJ333PjQҵPWURQJELrQÿӝQKӓKѫQKRһF EҵQJ1JKƭDOjQӃXÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ 333WURQJSKҥPYLQKӓKѫQWKuYүQNӃWOXұQ OjWӗQWҥL333OjGRWӗQWҥLFiFFKLSKtYұQWҧL EҧRKLӇPWKXӃôWURQJWKѭѫQJPҥLTXӕFWӃ .ӃWOXұQ %jL EiR WKӵF KLӋQ QKҵP NLӇP ÿӏQK Vӵ WӗQ WҥL QJDQJ JLi VӭF PXD 333 JLӳD 7KiL /DQ 0DOD\VLDYj9LӋW1DP9ӟLFiFKWLӃSFұQNKiF VRYӟLFiFQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟFQJKLrQFӭXQj\WuP WKҩ\ Vӵ WӗQ WҥL QJDQJ JLi VӭFPXD 333 WURQJ GjLKҥQJLӳD9LӋW1DPYj7KiL/DQWURQJYQJ ÿѭӡQJ333YӟLSKҥPYLQKӓKѫQQKѭQJOҥL NӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭXNK{QJFKR WKҩ\Vӵ WӗQ WҥL 333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLDYӟLÿӝOӋFKUD NKӓLÿѭӡQJ333OjWUrQ /ờGRJLҧLWKtFKFKRVӵWӗQWҥLKD\NK{QJWӗQ WҥLFӫDOờWKX\ӃW333[XҩWSKiWWӯQKLӅXQJX\rQ QKkQĈӕLYӟL7KiL/DQPһFG OҥPSKiW FӫD TXӕFJLDQj\WKҩSKѫQQKLӅXVRYӟL9LӋW1DPYj FKӍEҵQJVRYӟLOҥPSKiWFӫD9LӋW1DPWURQJ VXӕWJLDLÿRҥQQJKLrQFӭXQKѭQJGR7KiL/DQ WKӵFKLӋQFKtQKViFKWӹJLiWӯFӕÿӏQKVDQJOLQK KRҥWWLӃQÿӃQWKҧQәLWӯVDXNKӫQJKRҧQJQăP ÿm OjPJLi WUӏ7+%ÿLӅXFKӍQK OLQKKRҥW KѫQVRYӟLTXӕFJLDFyTXDQKӋWKѭѫQJPҥLĈӕL YӟL0DOD\VLD Oj ÿӕL WiF WKѭѫQJPҥL OӟQ WKӭ VDX7KiL/DQYjOjTXӕFJLDNK{QJWӗQWҥL333 +uQK3KkQEӕÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ QJDQJJLiVӭFPXD333 97ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ 7jLNKҧRWKDPNKҧR Bahmani2VNRRHHDQG5DWKD7KH%LODWHUDO-&XUYH6ZHGHQYHUVXVKHU0DMRU Trading Partners. ,QWHUQDWLRQDO-RXUQDORI$SSOLHG(FRQRPLF %DXP&)%DUNRXODV-7&DJOD\DQ01RQOLQHDUDGMXVWPHQWWRSXUFKDVLQJSRZHU SDULW\LQWKHSRVW%UHWWRQ:RRGVHUD-RXUQDO,QWHUQDWLRQDO0RQH\DQG)LQDQFH± %ROOHUVOHY7*HQHUDOL]HG$XWRUHJUHVVLYH&RQGLWLRQDO+HWHURVNHGDVWLFLW\-RXUQDO RI(FRQRPHWULF &DUYDOKR&1HFKLR) $JJUHJDWLRQDQG WKH333SX]]OH LQD VWLFN\SULFHPRGHO $PHULFDQ(FRQRPLF5HYLHZ± &KHQ:$QDO\]LQJPXOWLSOHQRQOLQHDUWLPHVHULHVZLWKH[WHQGHG*UDQJHUFDXVDOLW\ 3K\VLFV/HWWHUV$± *LUDLWLV/.DSHWDQLRV*<DWHV7,QIHUHQFHRQVWRFKDVWLFWLPHYDU\LQJFRHI¿FLHQW models.-RXUQDORI(FRQRPHWULFV± &KRQJ< -RUGiẽ7D\ORU$07KH+DUURG±%DODVVD±6DPXHOVRQK\SRWKHVLV UHDO H[FKDQJHUDWHVDQGWKHLUORQJUXQHTXLOLEULXP,QWHUQDWLRQDO(FRQRPLF5HYLHZ± (QJOH5$XWRUHJUHVVLYH&RQGLWLRQDO+HWHURVFHGDVWLFLW\ZLWK(VWLPDWHVRI9DULDQFH RI8QLWHG.LQJGRP,QÀDWLRQ(FRQRPHWULFD *DR -  1RQOLQHDU 7LPH 6HULHV 6HPLSDUDPHWULF DQG 1RQSDUDPHWULF 0HWK RGV/RQGRQ&KDSPDQDQG+DOO&5& *UDQJHU&:-6WUDWHJLHVIRU0RGHOOLQJ1RQOLQHDU7LPH6HULHV5HODWLRQVKLSV(FR QRPLF5HFRUG +DQQDQ(-7KHDV\PSWRWLFWKHRU\RIOLQHDUWLPHVHULHVPRGHOV-RXUQDORI$SSOLH 3UREDELOLW\ +HFNVFKHU ()  9l[HONXUVHQV JUXQGYDO YLG SDSSHUVP\QWIRW(NRQRPLVN 7LGVNULIW ± +RQJ6+3KLOOLSV3&%7HVWLQJOLQHDULW\LQFRLQWHJUDWLQJUHODWLRQVZLWKDQDSSOLFD- tion to purchasing power parity.-RXUQDORI%XVLQHVV(FRQRPLF6WDWLVWLFV± /L H./LQ Z.Yj+VLDR C., . Testing purchasing power parity hypothesis: a semipara- PHWULFYDU\LQJFRHI¿FLHQWDSSURDFK(PSLULFDO(FRQRPLFV 0LFKDHO:0(GHU36DQG'UH\IXVV*7KH.QXFOHDUVKXWWOLQJGRPDLQ$QRY- HOVLJQDOIRUQXFOHDULPSRUWDQGQXFOHDUH[SRUWLQWKHKQ513.SURWHLQ(0%2-± YӟL9LӋW1DPWURQJJLDLÿRҥQQJKLrQFӭXOjGR FKrQKOӋFKOҥPSKiW9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLDNKi FDRPӭFWUXQJEuQKWUrQWѭѫQJWӵQKѭ7KiL /DQQKѭQJFKtQKViFKWӹJLiFӫD0DOD\VLDNKi FӭQJQKҳFQHRFӕÿӏQKYjR86'WURQJWKӡLJLDQ GjLÿӃQQăPEҳWÿҫXÿLӅXFKӍQKOLQKKRҥW KѫQ1KѭYұ\NKL[iFÿӏQK WӹJLiFKpR0<5 91' WKu ÿѭѫQJ QKLrQ 0<5 OrQ JLi VR YӟL 91'/ҥPSKiW9LӋW1DPFDRKѫQ0DOD\VLDOӁ UD91'SKҧLJLҧPJLiQKѭQJNKL0<5JLҧPJLi VkXKѫQVRYӟL86'WKu91'OҥLWLӃSWөFOrQJLi Yjÿk\OjQJX\rQQKkQFKӫ\ӃXJLҧLWKtFKFKRVӵ NK{QJWӗQWҥL333JLӳD9LӋW1DPYj0DOD\VLD YӟLÿӝOӋFKUDNKӓLÿѭӡQJ333Oj 10 7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ 2ả&RQQHOO3*-:HL6-7KHELJJHUWKH\DUHWKHKDUGHUWKH\IDOOWKHUHWDLOSULFH differences across US cities. -RXUQDORI,QWHUQDWLRQDO(FRQRPLFV± 3HVDUDQ0+6PLWK5RQ3<DPDJDWD7DQG+YR]G\N/3DLUZLVHWHVWVRISXU- chasing power parity, (FRQRPHWULF5HYLHZVSS,661 6XQ< /L 4 'DWDGULYHQ EDQGZLGWK VHOHFWLRQ IRU QRQVWDWLRQDU\ VHPLSDUDPHWULF models.-RXUQDORI%XVLQHVVDQG(FRQRPLFV6WDWLVWLFV± 7D\ORU037KH(FRQRPLFVRI([FKDQJH5DWHV-RXUQDORI(FRQRPLF/LWHUDWXUH, 33:  7D\ORU033HHO'$6DUQR/1RQOLQHDUPHDQUHYHUVLRQLQUHDOH[FKDQJHUDWHVWR- ward a solution to the purchasing power parity puzzles. ,QWHUQDWLRQDO(FRQRPLF5HYLHZ±  7D\ORU$0$&HQWXU\RI3XUFKDVLQJ3RZHU3DULW\7KH5HYLHZRI(FRQRPLFVDQG 6WDWLVWLFV 7RQJ+1RQOLQHDU7LPH6HULHV$'\QDPLFDO6\VWHP$SSURDFK2[IRUG2[IRUG University Press. ;LDR =  )XQFWLRQDOFRHI¿FLHQW FRLQWHJUDWLQJ UHJUHVVLRQ -RXUQDO RI (FRQRPLFV ±