Tài liệu Biến đổi khí hậu, hiệu quả kinh doanh và vai trò điều tiết của sở hữu nhà nước tại các công ty phát điện: Bằng chứng thực nghiệm tại Việt Nam: 35
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
%,ӂ1ĈӘ,.+ậ+Ұ8+,ӊ848Ҧ.,1+'2$1+9ơ9$,75ẹĈ,ӄ87,ӂ7&Ӫ$
6Ӣ+Ӳ81+ơ1ѬӞ&7Ҥ,&ẩ&&é1*7<3+ẩ7Ĉ,ӊ1%Ҵ1*&+Ӭ1*7+Ӵ&
1*+,ӊ07Ҥ,9,ӊ71$0
&/,0$7(&+$1*(%86,1(663(5)250$1&($1'7+(5(*8/$725<
52/(2)67$7(2:1(56+,3,132:(5*(1(5$7,21&203$1,(6(03,5,-
&$/(9,'(1&(,19,(71$0
3K̩P4X͙F%̫R1
1Jj\QKұQ 1Jj\QKұQEҧQVӱD 1Jj\ÿăQJ
7yPWҳW
1JKLrQFӭXQj\SKkQWtFKWiFÿӝQJFӫDELӃQÿәLNKtKұX%Ĉ.+YjYDLWUzÿLӅXWLӃWFӫDVӣKӳX
1KjQѭӟF6+11ÿӃQKLӋXTXҧNLQKGRDQK+4.'FiFF{QJW\SKiWÿLӋQ&73Ĉӣ9LӋW1DP
.ӃWTXҧFKR WKҩ\%Ĉ.+Fy WiFÿӝQJÿӃQ+4.'YjFKLSKtJLiYӕQFӫD&73ĈNӃWTXҧ WKӵF
QJKLӋPFNJQJFKRWKҩ\WӹOӋVӣKӳX1KjQѭӟFFDROjPJLҧP+4.'.ӃWTXҧWѭѫQJWӵNKLSKkQWtFK
WiFÿӝQJFӫD6+11WK{QJTXDELӃQFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQ9jLWUzÿLӅXWLӃWFӫD6+11WKӇKLӋQTXDELӃQ
WѭѫQJWiFNӃWTXҧELӃQWѭѫQJWiFOjPWăQJOӧLQKXұ...
13 trang |
Chia sẻ: quangot475 | Lượt xem: 389 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu Biến đổi khí hậu, hiệu quả kinh doanh và vai trò điều tiết của sở hữu nhà nước tại các công ty phát điện: Bằng chứng thực nghiệm tại Việt Nam, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
35
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
%,ӂ1ĈӘ,.+ậ+Ұ8+,ӊ848Ҧ.,1+'2$1+9ơ9$,75ẹĈ,ӄ87,ӂ7&Ӫ$
6Ӣ+Ӳ81+ơ1ѬӞ&7Ҥ,&ẩ&&é1*7<3+ẩ7Ĉ,ӊ1%Ҵ1*&+Ӭ1*7+Ӵ&
1*+,ӊ07Ҥ,9,ӊ71$0
&/,0$7(&+$1*(%86,1(663(5)250$1&($1'7+(5(*8/$725<
52/(2)67$7(2:1(56+,3,132:(5*(1(5$7,21&203$1,(6(03,5,-
&$/(9,'(1&(,19,(71$0
3K̩P4X͙F%̫R1
1Jj\QKұQ 1Jj\QKұQEҧQVӱD 1Jj\ÿăQJ
7yPWҳW
1JKLrQFӭXQj\SKkQWtFKWiFÿӝQJFӫDELӃQÿәLNKtKұX%Ĉ.+YjYDLWUzÿLӅXWLӃWFӫDVӣKӳX
1KjQѭӟF6+11ÿӃQKLӋXTXҧNLQKGRDQK+4.'FiFF{QJW\SKiWÿLӋQ&73Ĉӣ9LӋW1DP
.ӃWTXҧFKR WKҩ\%Ĉ.+Fy WiFÿӝQJÿӃQ+4.'YjFKLSKtJLiYӕQFӫD&73ĈNӃWTXҧ WKӵF
QJKLӋPFNJQJFKRWKҩ\WӹOӋVӣKӳX1KjQѭӟFFDROjPJLҧP+4.'.ӃWTXҧWѭѫQJWӵNKLSKkQWtFK
WiFÿӝQJFӫD6+11WK{QJTXDELӃQFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQ9jLWUzÿLӅXWLӃWFӫD6+11WKӇKLӋQTXDELӃQ
WѭѫQJWiFNӃWTXҧELӃQWѭѫQJWiFOjPWăQJOӧLQKXұQYjOjPWăQJJLiYӕQFKRFiF&73Ĉ1JKƭDOj
6+11FDRÿLFQJYӟL%Ĉ.+JL~SFiF&73ĈFyPӭFVLQKOӡLFDRKѫQPһFGFKLSKtFyWăQJKѫQ
1JRjLUDQJKLrQFӭXFNJQJWuPWKҩ\YD\QӧQKLӅXYjTX\P{OӟQKѫQOjPJLҧP+4.'FӫD&73Ĉ
7ӯNKyDELӃQÿәLNKtKұXVӣKӳXQKjQѭӟFF{QJW\SKiWÿLӋQ
$EVWUDFW
This study analyzes the effects of climate change and the regulatory role of state ownership on the
business performance of power generation companies in Vietnam. The results show that climate
change has an impact on business performance, and cost of capital for power generation compa-
QLHV([SHULPHQWDOUHVXOWVDOVRVKRZWKDWWKHSHUFHQWDJHRIVWDWHRZQHUVKLSGHFUHDVHVEXVLQHVVSHU-
formance. Similar results were obtained when analyzing the impact of state ownership through the
DJHQF\FRVW7KHUHJXODWRU\UROHRIVWDWHRZQHUVKLSLVUHÀHFWHGLQWKHLQWHUDFWLRQYDULDEOHUHVXOWLQJ
in incremental returns and increased capital costs for power generation companies. Meaning that
high state ownership goes hand in hand with climate change, which makes it possible for electrici-
W\JHQHUDWRUVWRKDYHKLJKHUSUR¿WDELOLW\OHYHOVDOEHLWDWDKLJKHUFRVW,QDGGLWLRQWKHVWXG\IRXQG
that larger debt and bigger size reduced the performance of the generator business.
.H\ZRUGVclimate change, state ownership, power generation companies
7әQJ&{QJW\ĈLӋQOӵF73+&0
*LӟLWKLӋX
%Ĉ.+ Oj PӝW WURQJ QKӳQJ WKiFK WKӭF OӟQ
QKҩWÿӕLYӟLWRjQQKkQORҥLWURQJWKӃNӹYj
FiFWKӃNӹWLӃSWKHRÿmÿDQJYjVӁOjPWKD\ÿәL
WRjQGLӋQVkXVҳFTXiWUuQKSKiW WULӇQFӫDFiF
TXӕFJLDWURQJÿyFy9LӋW1DP7X\QKLrQӢ
9LӋW1DPFKѭDFyQKLӅXWUDQKOXұQYӅҧQKKѭӣQJ
FӫD%Ĉ.+ÿӃQKLӋXTXҧKRҥWÿӝQJ&73Ĉ%jL
QJKLrQFӭXQj\VӁSKkQWtFKYjFXQJFҩSQKӳQJ
EҵQJ FKӭQJ NKRD KӑF OѭӧQJ KyDPӭF ÿӝ ҧQK
KѭӣQJ FӫD%Ĉ.+ FҩX WU~F Vӣ KӳX FQJPӝW
Vӕ\ӃXWӕNKiFQKѭFҩXWU~FYӕQPӭFFKLWLrX
YӕQôÿӃQKLӋXTXҧKRҥWÿӝQJ&73Ĉ1JKLrQ
FӭXWұSWUXQJSKkQWtFKYDLWUzFӫD6+11WURQJ
FiF&73ĈFy JL~S FiF F{QJ W\ Qj\ JLҧPQKҽ
36
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
WiFÿӝQJFӫD%Ĉ.+KD\NK{QJ1JKLrQFӭXNǤ
YӑQJFiFNӃWTXҧÿҥWÿѭӧFVӁJL~StFKFKRQKj
TXҧQWUӏQKjÿҫXWѭFNJQJQKѭQKjKRҥFKÿӏQK
FKtQKViFKÿѭDUDFiFTX\ӃWÿӏQKÿ~QJÿҳQ
9DL WUz FӫD6+11 WURQJӭQJSKy YӟL
%Ĉ.+
&iFGRDQKQJKLӋS1KjQѭӟF '111FNJQJ
ÿyQJPӝWYDLWUzTXDQWUӑQJWURQJOƭQKYӵFSKiW
ÿLӋQ0D\HU 5DMDYXRULFKRELӃWSKҫQ
OӟQWjLVҧQFiFF{QJW\QăQJOѭӧQJWUrQWKӃJLӟL
WKXӝF Vӣ KӳX'111&KtQK SKӫ FNJQJ Fy WKӇ
ҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQF{QJW\WKXӝF6+11WK{QJTXD
TX\ӅQFәÿ{QJKD\QJѭӡLJySYӕQ&KtQKSKӫFy
WKӇWKӵFKLӋQFiFTX\ӅQELӇXTX\ӃWFӫDFәÿ{QJ
YjVRҥQWKҧRQKӳQJFKtQKViFKÿӇFiFF{QJW\
WKXӝF6+11 WKӵFKLӋQÿӇ WK~Fÿҭ\JLҧPQKҽ
FiFWiFÿӝQJFӫD%Ĉ.+/LX .RNNR
,3&&
7URQJQKӳQJWKұSNӹTXDFiFQKjKRҥFKÿӏQK
FKtQKViFKÿmWKӵFKLӋQPӝWORҥWFiFJLҧLSKiS
*ҫQÿk\&OzYjFiFWiFJLҧFKRUҵQJFiF
F{QJFөQKѭWKXӃFDUERQKD\WKӏWUѭӡQJPXDEiQ
NKtWKҧLÿѭӧFVӱGөQJÿӇJLҧLTX\ӃWYҩQÿӅYӅ
P{LWUѭӡQJQKѭ%Ĉ.+WUrQSKҥPYLWRjQFҫX
&iFF{QJFөQj\WҥRUDFKLSKtÿӇÿiQKÿәLKLӋX
TXҧJLҧPSKiWWKҧLNKtQKjNtQK*+*&KtQK
SKӫFyWKӇNLӇPVRiWWUӵFWLӃSPӝWVӕ'111ÿӇ
FyWKӇJLҧLTX\ӃWWӕWFiFYҩQÿӅP{LWUѭӡQJEҵQJ
FiFKÿӏQKKuQKFiFWUiFKQKLӋPYӟLP{LWUѭӡQJ
FӫD GRDQKQJKLӋSĈk\ FKtQK Oj Fѫ Vӣ ÿӇ FiF
QJKLrQFӭXÿiQKJLiYҩQÿӅ[ӱ OờP{L WUѭӡQJ
WҥL FiF'111Fy ҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQ+4.'KD\
NK{QJ7KұWYұ\&OzYjFiFWiFJLҧOұS
OXұQUҵQJWURQJWUѭӡQJKӧSNK{QJFyTX\ÿӏQK
UjQJEXӝFYӅP{LWUѭӡQJÿӇWӕLÿDKyDFiFPөF
WLrXNLQKGRDQKKjQKYLFӫDQKjTXҧQWUӏ'111
YjGRDQKQJKLӋSWѭQKkQFyWKӇWѭѫQJÿӗQJYӅ
YҩQÿӅOLrQTXDQÿӃQP{LWUѭӡQJ1JѭӧFOҥLNKL
Fy FiF TX\ ÿӏQK UjQJ EXӝF'111 Yj GRDQK
QJKLӋSWѭQKkQVӁFyKjQKYLWӕLÿDKyDFKLSKt
ELrQNKiFQKDXĈLӅXQj\ҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQKjQK
YLJLҧLTX\ӃWFiFYҩQÿӅWUiFKQKLӋPFӝQJÿӗQJ
OLrQTXDQÿӃQP{LWUѭӡQJYj+4.'FӫDF{QJ
ty.
&iFEҵQJFKӭQJWKӵFQJKLӋP
.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭXWKӵFQJKLӋPFiFGRDQK
QJKLӋSQJjQKÿLӋQFӫD&OzYjFiFWiFJLҧ
WҥL FiF TXӕF JLD &KkX ặX JLDL ÿRҥQ ±
FKR WKҩ\ FiF '111 QJjQK ÿLӋQ Fy Wӹ
VXҩWVLQKOӧLWKҩSKѫQVRYӟLPӭFWUXQJEuQKNKL
ÿҧPÿѭѫQJFiFQKLӋPYөJLҧPSKiWWKҧLNKLQKj
NtQK&iF'111FKҩSQKұQPӝWPӭFVLQKOӧL
WKҩSÿӇFkQEҵQJQKXFҫXFӫD[mKӝLOjEҧRYӋ
P{LWUѭӡQJ7URQJPӝWVӕWUѭӡQJKӧS'111
FNJQJFyWKӇÿӕLGLӋQYӟLWuQKWUҥQJFăQJWKҷQJ
WjLFKtQKNKLFKҩSQKұQPӭFVLQKOӧLWKҩS
&iFQJKLrQFӭXYӅYDL WUzFӫD6+11WURQJ
ӭQJSKyYӟL%Ĉ.+NK{QJQKLӅXQJRjL&OzYj
FiFWiFJLҧPӝWVӕQJKLrQFӭXNKiFWұS
WUXQJYjRWiFÿӝQJFӫDVӵNLӋQOLrQTXDQÿӃQ{
QKLӉPP{LWUѭӡQJYjJLiFәSKҫQFiFF{QJW\
NӃWTXҧFKRWKҩ\WURQJKҫXKӃWFiFWUѭӡQJKӧS
FiFF{QJEӕWK{QJWLQOLrQTXDQÿӃQYLӋFF{QJW\
Jk\UD{QKLӉPP{LWUѭӡQJJLiFәSKLӃXF{QJW\
JLҧPĈLӅXQj\KjPờFiFYҩQÿӅ[ҩXOLrQTXDQ
ÿӃQP{LWUѭӡQJOjPJLҧP+4.'FӫDF{QJW\
&iFQJKLrQFӭXÿLӇQKuQKQKѭ+DPLOWRQ
.ODVVHQ 0F/DXJKOLQ.KDQQDYjFiF
WiF JLҧ ô WuP WKҩ\ JLҧP SKiW WKҧL NKt
Jk\KҥLWăQJKLӋXTXҧWjLFKtQKYjWLӃWNLӋPWLӅQ
FKRF{QJW\7X\QKLrQFiFF{QJW\WURQJOƭQK
YӵFF{QJQJKLӋSFyKLӋXTXҧ WKҩSKѫQ VRYӟL
PӝWVӕOƭQKYӵFNKiF(OHIWKHULDGLVYjFӝQJVӵ
QJKLrQ FӭX WiF ÿӝQJ FӫD %Ĉ.+ ÿӃQ
KLӋXTXҧKRҥWÿӝQJFiFF{QJW\ӣ+\OҥS'ӵD
YjRGӳOLӋXNKҧRViWFiFF{QJEӕWK{QJWLQOLrQ
TXDQÿӃQ%Ĉ.+YjFiFFKӍVӕÿROѭӡQJ+4.'
FiFWiFJLҧWuPWKҩ\PӕLTXDQKӋPұWWKLӃWJLӳD
+4.'52$Yj%Ĉ.+
7ҥL9LӋW1DPVӕOѭӧQJFiFQJKLrQFӭXKjQ
OkPFKX\rQVkXWuPKLӇXYӅ+4.'QJjQKÿLӋQ
ӣ9LӋW1DPFzQUҩWKҥQFKӃ7URQJNKLÿyPӝW
Vӕ QJKLrQ FӭX OLrQ TXDQ ÿӃQ FiF \ӃX Wӕ ҧQK
KѭӣQJÿӃQ+4.'ӣFiFGRDQKQJKLӋSWҥL9LӋW
1DPWKѭӡQJORҥLNKӓLPүXQJKLrQFӭXFKѭDFy
WKҧR OXұQ ULrQJELӋW FKX\rQ VkXYӅFiF&73Ĉ
1JX\ӉQ4XӕF1JKLYj0DL9ăQ1DP
9};XkQ9LQKĈRjQ9LQK7KăQJ
&iFQJKLrQFӭXYӅ%Ĉ.+WUѭӟFÿk\FNJQJFKѭD
Fy QKLӅX WUDQK OXұQ YDL WUz ÿLӅX WLӃW FӫD1Kj
QѭӟFWҥLFiF&73ĈWURQJNLӇPVRiW%Ĉ.+WURQJ
FiFQӅQNLQKWӃFKX\ӇQÿәL.KLPӣFӱDOƭQKYӵF
NLQKGRDQKSKiWÿLӋQFKRWѭQKkQWKDPJLDYj
WK~F ÿҭ\ SKiW WULӇQ F{QJ QJKLӋS FiF TXӕF JLD
37
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
7URQJÿy
- )3)LM Oj ELӃQ ÿҥL GLӋQ FKR NӃW TXҧ NLQK
GRDQKFӫDF{QJty iWҥLQăPM)3)LMVӱGөQJ
FiFWKѭӟFÿREDRJӗP52$52(OjPÿҥL
GLӋQ
- $5M OjELӃQÿҥLGLӋQFKRPӭFÿӝ%Ĉ.+WҥL
9LӋW1DPWURQJQăPM$5MVӱGөQJFiFÿҥL
GLӋQEDRJӗPWKD\ÿәLOѭӧQJPѭDWKD\ÿәL
QKLӋWÿӝWUXQJEuQKQăP
- 2:1LMOjELӃQÿҥLGLӋQFKRWӹOӋVӣKӳXYӕQ
1KjQѭӟFFӫDF{QJW\LWURQJQăPM
- $5[2:1OjELӃQWѭѫQJWiF ÿӇSKkQWtFKYDL
WUzÿLӅXWLӃWFӫD6+11
- $&LM Yj$&LMOҫQOѭӧWOjWӹOӋFKLSKtKRҥW
ÿӝQJWUrQGRDQKWKXYjWӹOӋGRDQKWKXWUrQ
WәQJWjLVҧQ+DLELӃQQj\ÿѭӧFVӱGөQJÿR
OѭӡQJFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQ
- ;LM Oj WұSKӧSFiFELӃQNLӇPVRiWÿѭDYjR
P{KuQKEDRJӗP
/(9LM Oj ELӃQ ÿҥL GLӋQ FKR Wӹ OӋ Vӱ
GөQJQӧFӫD F{QJ W\ L WURQJQăP M
ÿzQEҭ\WjLFKtQK
/,4LMOjNKҧQăQJWKDQKWRiQ;
SIZEi,j TX\P{F{QJW\
- Į, ȕ, Ȝ, įį, , , 3OjFiFWKDPVӕWURQJP{
KuQK
- XLM OjVDLVӕP{KuQK
;iFÿӏQKFiFELӃQWURQJP{KuQKÿӏQK
OѭӧQJ
%Ĉ.+Yj+4.'
&iFQJKLrQFӭXYӅҧQKKѭӣQJFӫD%Ĉ.+OrQ
FXQJFҫXÿLӋQVӱGөQJFKӍWLrXWKD\ÿәLQKLӋWÿӝ
YjOѭӧQJPѭDQKѭ%HQHVWDG&RQVLGLQH
'HPHUV& 5R\QKLӋWÿӝFNJQJOj
\ӃXWӕҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQWUX\ӅQWҧLÿLӋQ(VNHODQG
YjFiF WiFJLҧ /LrQKӋYӟL WKӵF WӃ WҥL
9LӋW1DPGӳ OLӋXSKkQ WtFK%Ĉ.+Fy WKӇFy
VҹQVӕ OLӋX WKӕQJNrFKӍFyQKLӋWÿӝYj OѭӧQJ
PѭD1JjQKÿLӋQFӫD9LӋW1DPFNJQJGӵDYjR
WKӫ\ÿLӋQUҩWQKLӅXQrQQKLӋWÿӝYjOѭӧQJPѭD
FyWKӇOjQKӳQJ\ӃXWӕFKLSKӕLÿӃQ+4.'FiF
&73Ĉ'R ÿy QJKLrQ FӭX Vӱ GөQJ FiFK WLӃS
FұQKuQKWKӭFELӇXKLӋQFӫD%Ĉ.+WK{QJTXD
FiF \ӃX Wӕ FKrQK OӋFK OѭӧQJPѭD KRһF QKLӋW
ÿӝWUXQJEuQKKҵQJQăPVRYӟLWUXQJEuQKFӫD
\ӃXWӕÿyQăPWUѭӟFÿy%ӝ7jLQJX\rQYj
M{L WUѭӡQJ Yj1JX\ӉQ9ăQ7KҳQJ Yj
FiF WiF JLҧ NKiF .KL ÿy JLi WUӏ WUXQJ
EuQKOѭӧQJPѭDKҵQJQăPFiFK[DJLiWUӏWUXQJ
EuQKQăPWUѭӟFÿySKҧQiQKNKLKұXÿmWKD\
ÿәLNKҳFQJKLӋWKѫQ1ӃXJLiWUӏWUXQJEuQKKҵQJ
QăPOӟQKѫQJLiWUӏWUXQJEuQKQăPSKҧQiQK
OѭӧQJPѭDWăQJOrQTXiPӭFQJѭӧFOҥLQySKҧQ
QKѭ9LӋW1DPFyWKӵFKLӋQYDLWUzÿLӅXWLӃWJL~S
NLӇPVRiW%Ĉ.+QyLFKXQJYjJL~SFiFF{QJW\
FyYӕQFKLSKӕLFӫD1KjQѭӟFJLҧPWiFÿӝQJEҩW
OӧL FӫD%Ĉ.+QKѭFiFQӅQNLQK WӃSKiW WULӇQ
KD\NK{QJ
0{KuQK SKѭѫQJSKiSQJKLrQ FӭX Yj
GӳOLӋX
0{KuQKQJKLrQFӭX
.Ӄ WKӯD FiF QJKLrQ FӭXQKѭ ,ZDWD 2ND-
GD 9LWKHVVRQWKLD -LWWLPD 7RQJXUDL
&Oz Yj FiF WiF JLҧ QJKLrQ FӭX
ÿӅ[XҩWP{KuQKÿӏQK OѭӧQJ WiFÿӝQJFӫDFҩX
WU~FVӣKӳXYj%Ĉ.+YjFiF\ӃXWӕNKiFÿӃQ
+4.'FiF&73Ĉӣ9LӋW1DPGѭӟLGҥQJKjP
VӕÿDELӃQQKѭP{KuQK.
ܨܲ݅ܨ ,݆ = ߙ + ߚ1ܣܴ݆ +ߚ2 ܣܴ݆ ݔ ܱܹ ݅ܰ ,݆ + ߣ1ܱܹ ݅ܰ,݆ + ߜ1ܣܥ1݅ ,݆ + ߜ2ܣܥ2݅ ,݆ +ߠ݇ ݅ܺ ,݆ + ݑ݅ ,݆
3
݇=1
(1)
38
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
9DLWUzÿL͉XWL͇WFͯD6+11WURQJNL͋PVRiW
%Ĉ.+̫QKK˱ͧQJÿ͇Q+4.'
9ӅOờWKX\ӃWQKѭQrXӣSKҫQ&KtQKSKӫFy
WKӇҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQF{QJW\WKXӝF6+11WK{QJ
TXDTX\ӅQFәÿ{QJKD\QJѭӡLJySYӕQ&KtQK
SKӫFyWKӇWKӵFKLӋQFiFTX\ӅQELӇXTX\ӃWFӫD
Fәÿ{QJYjVRҥQWKҧRQKӳQJFKtQKViFKÿӇFiF
F{QJ W\ WKXӝF 6+11 WKӵF KLӋQ ÿӇ WK~F ÿҭ\
JLҧPQKҽFiFWiFÿӝQJFӫD%Ĉ.+
7KӵFWӃ&KtQKSKӫ9LӋW1DPÿmSKrFKXҭQ
FiFFDPNӃWTXӕFWӃYӅ%Ĉ.+ĈҫXWLrQ&{QJ
ѭӟF.KXQJFӫD/LrQ+LӋS4XӕFYӅ%Ĉ.+ÿm
ÿѭӧF&KtQKSKӫ9LӋW1DPSKrFKXҭQQJj\
WKiQJQăP7LӃSWKHR&KtQKSKӫ9LӋW
1DPFNJQJÿmSKrFKXҭQ1JKӏÿӏQKWKѭ.\RWR
QJj\ WKiQJ QăP/XұW EҧR YӋ0{L
WUѭӡQJFNJQJÿmÿѭӧF4XӕFKӝLWK{QJTXDQăP
FNJQJQrXU}&KtQKSKӫ9LӋW1DPVҹQVjQJ
WKӵFKLӋQFiFFDPNӃWYjQJKƭDYөTXӕF WӃYӅ
EҧRYӋP{LWUѭӡQJPj9LӋW1DPÿmNờ4X\ӃW
ÿӏQKVӕ4Ĉ77*QJj\FӫD7Kӫ
WѭӟQJ&KtQKSKӫ4Ĉ3KrGX\ӋW&KLӃQ
OѭӧF TXӕF JLD YӅ %Ĉ.+ ĈһF ELӋW 4Ĉ
FNJQJQrXEұWYDLWUzFKӫÿҥRFӫD1KjQѭӟFWURQJ
ӭQJ SKy YӟL%Ĉ.+7KHR ÿy1Kj QѭӟF WKӵF
KLӋQKRjQ WKLӋQFiFTX\KRҥFK FKtQK ViFKYj
FiF Fѫ FKӃ QJKLrQ FӭX NKRD KӑF FKӃ ÿӝ EiR
FiRJLiViWFҧQKEiRôFQJFiFTX\ÿӏQKWKX
K~W WKDP JLD FӫD NKX YӵF GRDQK QJKLӋS QKj
NKRDKӑFWKDPJLDFiFKRҥWÿӝQJWKtFKӭQJYӟL
%Ĉ.+YjJLҧPQKҽSKiWWKҧLNKtQKjNtQK
&KRÿӃQWKӡLÿLӇPQJKLrQFӭXWiFJLҧQKұQ
WKҩ\ WURQJPүX QJKLrQ FӭX Wӹ OӋ Vӣ KӳX FӫD
1Kj QѭӟF WURQJ &73Ĉ QLrP \ӃW ӣ PӭF
WUXQJEuQKSKҫQQKLӅXFiFF{QJW\FyPӭF
6+11WUrQFiELӋWFyWUѭӡQJKӧS6+11
WUrQ9ӟLFiFNKXQJSKiSOờYӯDQrXFQJ
YӟLWӹOӋVӣKӳXFDRWҥLFiF&73ĈWiFJLҧFKR
UҵQJ&KtQKSKӫ9LӋW1DPFNJQJFyWKӇWKӵFKLӋQ
NLӇPVRiW'111ÿӇFyWKӇJLҧLTX\ӃWFiFYҩQ
ÿӅ JLҧPQKҽ%Ĉ.+1ӃX YDL WUz 6+11SKiW
KX\QKѭOờWKX\ӃWFiF&73ĈFy6+11OӟQFy
WKӇFKӏXFKLSKӕLQKLӅXKѫQWӹVXҩWVLQKOӧLFӫD
FiFF{QJW\Qj\FyWKӇWKҩSKѫQĈӇNLӇPFKӭQJ
ÿLӅX Qj\ WiF JLҧ Vӱ GөQJ Nӻ WKXұW ELӃQ WѭѫQJ
WiF WiF JLҧ Eә VXQJ ELӃQ WѭѫQJ WiF JLӳD ELӃQ
ÿR OѭӡQJ%Ĉ.+ YjELӃQ6+11YjRP{KuQK
WKӵFQJKLӋP[2:1*LiWUӏWăQJOrQFӫDELӃQ
[2:1 SKҧQ iQK%Ĉ.+ OӟQ KѫQ Yj 6+11
WҥL FiF&73ĈFNJQJ OӟQKѫQ1ӃX6+11JL~S
&KtQK SKӫ NLӇP VRiW YҩQ ÿӅ %Ĉ.+ WKu WKHR
Oờ WKX\ӃW FӫD&OzYjFiF WiFJLҧ WKDP
VӕELӃQWѭѫQJWiFKӋVӕȕFyTXDQKӋQJѭӧF
FKLӅXYӟL+4.'
+L͏XͱQJFKLSKtÿ̩LGL͏Q
3KҫQYӕQ6+11WҥLFiFF{QJW\FyWKӇKuQK
WKjQKFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQ'RÿyPӝWVӕQKjQJKLrQ
iQKKҥQKiQJLDWăQJQJKLrPWUӑQJNKLQKLӋWÿӝ
WUXQJEuQKKҵQJQăPWăQJTXiOӟQVRYӟLJLiWUӏ
WUXQJEuQKSKҧQiQKWuQKKuQKNKtKұXFӵFÿRDQ
KD\NKҳFQJKLӋWKѫQ
ĈӕLYӟLFiFF{QJW\QKLӋWÿLӋQFiFF{QJW\
Qj\FKLӃPWӹWUӑQJQKӓWURQJPүXQJKLrQFӭX
+4.'FiFF{QJW\QKLӋWÿLӋQVӁFKӏXҧQKKѭӣQJ
FӫDQKXFҫXWLrXWKөÿLӋQWUX\ӅQGүQÿLӋQNKL
OѭӧQJPѭDQKLӋWÿӝKҵQJQăPWăQJKD\JLҧP
VRYӟL JLi WUӏ WUXQJEuQKҦQKKѭӣQJQj\ÿӃQ
+4.'WѭѫQJWӵQKѭFiFF{QJW\WKӫ\ÿLӋQ
%ҧQJ7әQJKӧSҧQKKѭӣQJFӫD%Ĉ.+ÿӃQ+4.'&73Ĉ
STT ĈӕLWѭӧQJ /ѭӧQJPѭD
JLҧPVRYӟL
WUXQJEuQK
/ѭӧQJPѭD
WăQJVRYӟL
WUXQJEuQK
1KLӋWÿӝWăQJ
VRYӟLWUXQJ
EuQK
1KLӋWÿӝ
JLҧPVRYӟL
WUXQJEuQK
+4.'&73Ĉ - + +RһF
-
+
KRһF
-
1JX͛Q7͝QJKͫSFͯDWiFJL̫
39
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
3KѭѫQJSKiSѭӟFOѭӧQJ
ĈһFÿLӇPFӫD+4.'FyWKӇWҥRUDKLӋQWѭӧQJ
+4.'KLӋQWҥLFyWKӇFKӏXWiFÿӝQJFӫDJLiWUӏ
NǤWUѭӟF9uOờGRÿyQJKLrQFӭXѭӟFOѭӧQJP{
KuQK YӟLGҥQJP{KuQKÿӝQJ WKHRSKѭѫQJ
SKiS*00QKѭÿӅ[XҩWFӫD Arellano & Bover
%OXQGHOO %RQG+ѫQQӳDYҩQ
ÿӅQӝLVLQKQKѭPӕLTXDQKӋKDLFKLӅXJLӳDELӃQ
JLҧLWKtFKYjELӃQSKөWKXӝFFyWKӇWӗQWҥL&KҷQJ
KҥQQKѭ+4.'WӕWKѫQQrQFiFF{QJW\FyWKӇ
FӭXVӱGөQJFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQQKѭELӃQWUXQJJLDQ
ÿӇÿiQKJLiWiFÿӝQJFӫD6+11ÿӃQ+4.'FӫD
F{QJW\$QJYjFiFWiFJLҧ6LQJK 'D-
YLGVRQ 7ѭѫQJWӵQKѭ6LQJK 'DYLGVRQ
FiFELӃQFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQÿROѭӡQJTXD
KDLELӃQJӗP$&Yj$&ÿѭӧF[iFÿӏQKQKѭ
sau:
$&%LӃQQj\ÿѭӧFÿROѭӡQJEҵQJWӹ
WUӑQJFKLSKtTXҧQOờYjFKLSKtEiQKjQJ
VR YӟL WәQJ GRDQK WKX WKXҫQ &KL SKt
TXҧQOờGRDQKQJKLӋSEDRJӗPFҧPӭF
OѭѫQJYjFiFNKRҧQWKXQKұSNKiFF{QJ
W\FKLWUҧFKRQKkQYLrQYjQKjTXҧQOờ
FiFFKLSKtNKiFQKѭWLӅQWKXrPXDGӏFK
YөYjFiFORҥLKjQJKyDKD\WjLVҧQQKѭ
FKLSKtFKRFiFWzDQKjYăQSKzQJWKLӃW
Eӏ[H{W{YjFiFWLӋQtFKWѭѫQJWӵNKiF
.KL[XQJÿӝWOӧLtFKJLӳDQKjTXҧQOờYj
F{QJW\FDRKѫQFKLSKtTXҧQOờYjEiQ
KjQJVRYӟLGRDQK WKXFy WKӇ OӟQKѫQ
1JKƭD Oj$& WăQJ OrQ VӁ OjP+4.'
JLҧP[XӕQJ
$& 7ӹ WUӑQJ GRDQK WKX WKXҫQ WUrQ
WәQJ WjL VҧQĈk\ Oj WKѭӟF ÿRPӭF ÿӝ
VӱGөQJ WjLVҧQKLӋXTXҧFӫDQKjTXҧQ
OờÿҥLGLӋQSKҫQYӕQ1KjQѭӟF 7ӹOӋ
GRDQK WKX WUrQ WjL VҧQ FDR FKR WKҩ\ Wӹ
OӋOӟQVӕOѭӧQJGRDQKWKXFDRKѫQÿѭӧF
WҥRUDWUrQÿѫQYӏWjLVҧQ+D\QyLFiFK
NKiFWjLVҧQÿѭӧFVӱGөQJWӕWÿӇWҥRUD
GzQJWLӅQÿyQJJySYjROӧLQKXұQ0ӝW
WӹOӋWKҩSVӁFKRWKҩ\QKjTXҧQOờÿDQJ
VӱGөQJWjLVҧQNpPKӑFyWKӇÿDQJOjP
VX\JLiWUӏKD\SKiKRҥLFiFPӕLOLrQNӃW
YӟLQJѭӡLODRÿӝQJNKiFKKjQJKD\ÿӕL
WiFQKjFXQJFҩSPj1KjQѭӟFPXӕQ
WҥR GӵQJ 1Kѭ Yұ\$& FDR KѫQ FKR
WKҩ\QKjTXҧQ OờTXҧQ WUӏKLӋXTXҧ Vӱ
GөQJWjLVҧQVLQKUDOӧLPjFәÿ{QJJLDR
SKy1JѭӧFOҥL$&JLҧPFKRWKҩ\QKj
TXҧQOờVӱGөQJFiFWjLVҧQFKѭDÿ~QJ
PөFÿtFKQKѭPRQJPXӕQFӫDFәÿ{QJ
1KѭYұ\FiFF{QJW\tWFy[XQJÿӝWOӧL
tFK$&VӁFDRKѫQVRYӟLFiFF{QJW\
Fy[XQJÿӝWOӧLtFK
0͙LTXDQK͏FͯDFiFEL͇QNL͋PVRiWYͣL
+4.'FͯD&73Ĉ
1JRjLFiF\ӃXWӕ%Ĉ.+YjFҩXWU~FVӣKӳX,
GӵDWUrQFiFQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟFÿk\QJKLrQFӭX
FNJQJ[k\GӵQJFiF\ӃXWӕSKҧQiQKFiFOӧLWKӃ
NKiFFӫDF{QJW\WiFÿӝQJÿӃQ+4.'Ĉk\Oj
FiF\ӃXWӕFyYDLWUzQKѭELӃQNLӇPVRiWWURQJ
P{KuQKKӗLTX\&iF\ӃXWӕEDRJӗPWӹOӋÿzQ
Eҭ\WӹOӋWKDQKWRiQKLӋQKjQKTX\P{F{QJW\
0ӕLTXDQKӋFӫDFiFELӃQNLӇPVRiWYӟL+4.'
ÿѭӧFWyPWҳWWURQJ%ҧQJ
%ҧQJ0ӕLTXDQKӋFӫDFiFELӃQNLӇPVRiWYӟL+4.'
677 %LӃQ 0ӕLTXDQKӋ 1JKLrQFӭXWUѭӟF
ĈzQEҭ\WjLFKtQK KRһF ,ZDWD 2NDGD
7ӹOӋWKDQKWRiQKLӋQKjQK - :DQJ
3 4X\P{F{QJW\ + ,ZDWD 2NDGD9}
;XkQ9LQK
40
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
WăQJFKLWLrXYӕQKRһFÿzQEҭ\WjLFKtQKWăQJOrQ
GR+4.'WӕWKѫQ9ҩQÿӅ6+11FyWKӇWKD\
ÿәLGR+4.'FӫDF{QJW\3KѭѫQJSKiS*00
JL~SJLҧLTX\ӃWYҩQÿӅQӝLVLQKWURQJP{KuQK
QJKLrQFӭX
ĈӇ WUiQK YҩQ ÿӅ RYHU ¿WWLQJ ELDV FiF WKLӃW
OұS ELӃQ F{QJ Fө ÿѭӧF JLӟL KҥQ 1JKLrQ FӭX
VӱGөQJELӃQWUӉVDLSKkQWKӭQKҩWFӫDELӃQQӝL
VLQKÿӇOұSELӃQF{QJFөW\FKӑQcollapseFNJQJ
ÿѭӧFiSGөQJĈLӅXQj\ÿҧPEҧRVӕELӃQF{QJ
Fө number of instruments QKӓKѫQ VӕQKyP
number of groups WURQJGӳ OLӋXEҧQJ9uGӳ
OLӋXQKӓQrQYLӋFVӱGөQJW\FKӑQÿLӅXFKӍQK
PүX QKӓ W\ FKӑQ small ÿӇ Vӱ GөQJ WKӕQJ
Nr W WKD\ Yu WKӕQJ Nr z ÿѭӧF GQJ FKR PүX
OӟQ Yj GQJ:DOO chi-VTXDUHG thay cho F-test
FNJQJÿѭӧF FKҩS QKұQ&XӕL FQJ J test YjC
testÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQÿӇÿiQKJLiWUӏELӃQF{QJFө
ÿѭӧFVӱGөQJ
'ӳOLӋXQJKLrQFӭX
7iFJLҧVӱGөQJGӳOLӋXWKXWKұSWӯEiRFiR
WjL FKtQK %&7& JLDL ÿRҥQ ± FӫD
F{QJW\ÿmQLrP\ӃWWUrQFiFVӣJLDRGӏFKÿӇ
SKkQWtFKÿӏQKOѭӧQJ
'ӳOLӋXYӅOѭӧQJPѭDYjQKLӋWÿӝWUXQJEuQK
KҵQJQăPÿѭӧFWKXWKұSWӯ7әQJFөF7KӕQJNr
9LӋW1DP *62 JLi WUӏ WUXQJ EuQK FӫD QKLӋW
ÿӝYjOѭӧQJPѭDJLDLÿRҥQ±*62
NK{QJFyVҹQQrQQJKLrQFӭXVӱGөQJGӳOLӋX
Wӯ FKX\rQ WUDQJ ÿһF ELӋW YӅ NLӃQ WKӭF%Ĉ.+
&OLPDWH change knowledge portal ± &&.3
FӫD1JkQKjQJ7KӃJLӟL&iFJLiWUӏÿѭӧFWtQK
QKѭYj
ە
۔
ۓ οܶ݅ =
ܶ݅ െ ܣܸܶ݊ െ݇
ܣܸܶ݊ െ݇
(3)
οܴ݅ =
ܴ݅ െ ܣܸܴ݊െ݇
ܣܸܴ݊െ݇
(4)
7URQJÿyă7iYjă5iOjELӃQÿәLQKLӋWÿӝYjOѭӧQJPѭDQăPWKӭL
7LYj5LOjQKLӋWÿӝYjOѭӧQJPѭDQăP
6ӱGөQJSKҫQPӅP6WDWD
3 KWWSVGZHE[ZRUOGEDQNRUJFOLPDWHSRUWDOLQGH[FIP"SDJH GRZQVFDOHGBGDWDBGRZQ-
load&menu=historical
WKӭL
AVTn - k Yj$95n - k Oj JLi WUӏ QKLӋW ÿӝ
OѭӧQJPѭDWUXQJEuQKJLDLÿRҥQVRViQK
LOjQăPTXDQViWFiFQăP±
QNJLDLÿRҥQ±
7KӕQJNrP{Wҧ
&iFFKӍ WLrX WKӕQJNrP{ WҧGӳ OLӋXQJKLrQ
FӭX ÿѭӧF WUuQK Ej\ WURQJ %ҧQJ 'ӳ OLӋX
QJKLrQFӭXWURQJP{KuQKFyTXDQViW
ÿѭӧFWKXWKұSWURQJJLDLÿRҥQ±&iF
JLi WUӏ WUXQJ EuQK FӫD ELӃQ 52$ Yj 52( OҫQ
OѭӧW OjYj*Li WUӏ WUXQJEuQKFӫD
FiFELӃQÿҥLGLӋQFKR\ӃX Wӕ%Ĉ.+EDRJӗP
'591Yj'791 OҫQ OѭӧW Oj
Yj&iFJLi WUӏ Qj\FKR WKҩ\ OѭӧQJPѭD
YjQKLӋW ÿӝ WUXQJEuQKKҵQJQăPӣ9LӋW1DP
ÿDQJJLDWăQJVRYӟLWKӡLNǤQKӳQJQăP*Li
WUӏWUXQJFӫDELӃQÿҥLGLӋQFKRFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQ
JӗP$&Yj$& OҫQ OѭӧW OjYj
*LiWUӏWUXQJEuQKFӫDELӃQ6+11ӣPӭF
0ӭFÿӝELӃQÿӝQJFӫD6+11WӯYj
SKҫQQKLӅXӣPӭFWUrQĈLӅXQj\FKRWKҩ\
PһFGÿmQәOӵFJLҧPWӹOӋ6+11ӣFiF&73Ĉ
QKѭQJWӹOӋ6+11YүQӣPӭFFDR
%ҧQJP{WҧWѭѫQJTXDQFһSFiFELӃQWURQJP{
KuQKQJKLrQFӭX+ҫXKӃWFiFWUѭӡQJKӧSWѭѫQJ
TXDQJLӳDFiFELӃQÿӝFOұSÿӅXFyKӋVӕQKӓKѫQ
+ӋVӕWѭѫQJTXDQWKҩSFKRWKҩ\tWFyNKҧ
QăQJ[ҧ\UDKLӋQWѭӧQJÿDFӝQJWX\ӃQWURQJP{
KuQKWKӵFQJKLӋP%ҧQJFNJQJFKRWKҩ\FKӍ
Fy52(Yj'591FyWѭѫQJTXDQQJѭӧF
FKLӅXFzQOҥL52$Yj52(ÿӅXFyWѭѫQJTXDQ
FQJFKLӅXYӟLELӃQÿRWKD\ÿәLOѭӧQJPѭDYj
QKLӋWÿӝWUXQJEuQKKҵQJQăPVRYӟLQKӳQJQăP
1yL FiFKNKiF WѭѫQJTXDQFһSFKӍ UDPӕL
WѭѫQJTXDQFQJFKLӅXJLӳD+4.'Yj%Ĉ.+
NKL ELӃQ Qj\ ÿR EҵQJ WKD\ ÿәL QKLӋW ÿӝ WUXQJ
EuQKKҵQJQăP7ѭѫQJTXDQFһSFNJQJFKRWKҩ\
41
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
%ҧQJ7KӕQJNrP{WҧGӳOLӋXQJKLrQFӭX
%LӃQ 0{Wҧ
TXDQ
ViW
Trung
EuQK
6DLVӕ
FKXҭQ
1Kӓ
QKҩW
/ӟQ
QKҩW
52$
/ӧLQKXұQWUѭӟFWKXӃYjOmLYD\
7әQJWjLVҧQ
52(
/ӧLQKXұQWUѭӟFWKXӃYjOmLYD\YӕQ
FKӫVӣKӳX
'591
7KD\ÿәLOѭӧQJPѭDWUXQJEuQKQăP
GӳOLӋX*62VRYӟLWUXQJEuQKJLDL
ÿRҥQ
'791
7KD\ÿәLQKLӋWÿӝWUXQJEuQKQăP
GӳOLӋX*62VRYӟLWUXQJEuQKJLDL
ÿRҥQ
$&
&KLSKtTXҧQOờYjFKLSKtEiQKjQJ
'RDQKWKXWKXҫQ
$& 'RDQKWKXWKXҫQ7әQJWjLVҧQ
2:1 9ӕQWKXӝF6+119ӕQFKӫVӣKӳX
/(9 1ӧGjLKҥQ7әQJQJXӗQYӕQ
/,4 7jLVҧQQJҳQKҥQ1ӧQJҳQKҥQ
SIZE /Q7әQJWjLVҧQ
1JX͛Q7tQKWRiQFͯDWiFJL̫
%ҧQJ7ѭѫQJTXDQFһSFiFELӃQWURQJP{KuQK
ROA ROE DrVN
1960
DtVN
1960
AC1 AC2 OWN LEV LIQ
ROE 0.75 1
DRVN 0.02 -0.04 1
1960
DT VN 0.05 0.01 -0.54 1
1960
AC1 0.19 0.02 0.03 -0.04 1
AC2 0.33 0.28 0.02 0.04 0 1
OWN -0.15 -0.14 -0.04 -0.01 -0.3 0.14 1
LEV -0.64 -0.27 -0.06 -0.03 -0.41 -0.38 0.07 1
LIQ 0.33 0.11 -0.03 0.05 0.42 0.08 -0.03 -0.38 1
SIZE -0.43 -0.34 0.01 0.04 -0.4 -0.31 0.37 0.5 -0.11
+4.'Fy WѭѫQJTXDQFQJFKLӅXYӟL FKLSKt
ÿҥLGLӋQ$&Yj$&YjFyWѭѫQJTXDQQJѭӧF
FKLӅXYӟL6+112:17X\QKLrQÿk\FKӍOj
FiFGҩXKLӋXEDQÿҫXFKѭDSKҧLOjFѫVӣYӳQJ
FKҳFÿӇFKRFiFNӃWOXұQYӅFiFJLҧWKX\ӃWQJ-
KLrQFӭXEDQÿҫX
Nguồn: Tớnh toỏn của tỏc giả
42
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
.ӃWTXҧѭӟFOѭӧQJ
.ӃWTXҧP{KuQK
%ҧQJWUuQKEj\FiFNӃWTXҧѭӟFOѭӧQJP{
KuQK WKHR SKѭѫQJ SKiS*00KӋ WKӕQJ
EѭӟF&iFNLӇPÿӏQK+DQVHQ-WHVWYj&WHVW
ÿӅXFyPӭF[iFVXҩWOӟQKѫQĈLӅXQj\FKR
ELӃW FiF ELӃQ F{QJ Fө Vӱ GөQJ WURQJP{KuQK
SKKӧSYjFiFNӃWTXҧÿiQJWLQFұ\7URQJWҩW
FҧFiFP{KuQKVӕELӃQF{QJFөÿӅXQKӓKѫQVӕ
ÿѫQYӏ FKpR Vӕ F{QJ W\ WURQJPүXTXDQ ViW
&iFNLӇPÿӏQKYӅ WѭѫQJ WѭѫQJTXDQFKR WKҩ\
KҫXKӃW FiFP{KuQKNK{QJ Fy Wӵ WѭѫQJTXDQ
EұF &iF NӃW TXҧ ѭӟF OѭӧQJ FKR WKҩ\52$
Yj52(NǤQj\FyWѭѫQJTXDQFQJFKLӅXYӟL
52$Yj52(NǤWUѭӟFWURQJPӭFờQJKƭDWKӕQJ
Nr+D\QyLFiFKNKiF+4.'NǤQj\FKӏXҧQK
KѭӣQJFӫDNǤWUѭӟFQӃXNǤWUѭӟFWăQJNǤWLӃS
WKHRFNJQJWăQJ
ҦQKKѭӣQJFӫD%Ĉ.+ÿӃQ+4.'Ӣ%ҧQJ
FӝWYjFiFNӃWTXҧWuPWKҩ\WKD\ÿәLQKLӋW
ÿӝWUXQJEuQKKҵQJQăPVRYӟLQKѭQJQăP
'791 Fy TXDQ KӋ QJѭӧF FKLӅX YӟL
+4.'FiFKӋVӕFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr.ӃW
TXҧQj\FKRWKҩ\QӃXQKLӋWÿӝKҵQJQăPWăQJ
OrQ VR YӟL JLi WUӏ WUXQJ EuQK Fy WKӇ ELӇX KLӋQ
EҵQJKLӋQWѭӧQJKҥQKiQ[XҩWKLӋQQrQFyWKӇ
NKLӃQ FKR FiF QKjPi\ WKӫ\ ÿLӋQ SKҧL QJӯQJ
KRһFJLҧPF{QJVXҩWKRҥWÿӝQJĈLӅXQj\FKҳF
FKҳQ VӁ OjP WiF ÿӝQJ ÿӃQ+4.'FӫD&73Ĉ
7iFÿӝQJQj\OӟQKѫQVRYӟLWiFÿӝQJWăQJQKX
FҫXYӅÿLӋQ FӫDQJѭӡL WLrXGQJQrQNӃW TXҧ
FXӕLFQJOjPJLҧP+4.'FӫD&73Ĉ.ӃWTXҧ
Qj\FNJQJSKKӧSYӟLWKӵFWӃӣ9LӋW1DPYjR
QKӳQJWKiQJPDNK{QJѭӡLWLrXGQJWKѭӡQJ
QKұQQKLӅX OӡL NrXJӑL WLӃW NLӋPÿLӋQYj FKӏX
FҧQKEӏF~SÿLӋQOXkQSKLrQӣQKLӅXQѫL7KLӃX
KөWQJXӗQQѭӟFÿӇVҧQ[XҩWÿLӋQFKRWKӏWUѭӡQJ
WURQJNKLFiFFKLSKtNKҩXKDREҧRGѭӥQJPi\
PyFWKLӃWEӏWUX\ӅQWҧLÿLӋQFKLSKtTXҧQOờYүQ
GX\WUu&KRQrQYLӋFJLҧP+4.'OjÿLӅXNKy
WUiQK
&iFNӃWTXҧQj\OjEҵQJFKӭQJYӅPӕLTXDQ
KӋ QJѭӧF FKLӅX JLӳD %Ĉ.+ Yj +4.' FӫD
&73ĈQӃX%Ĉ.+ÿѭӧFÿҥLGLӋQEҵQJPӭFWKD\
ÿәL QKLӋW ÿӝ KҵQJQăP WăQJ OrQ VR YӟL JLi WUӏ
WUXQJEuQKQăPWUѭӟFÿy
7iFÿӝQJFӫD6+11CiFNӃWTXҧѭӟFOѭӧQJ
FKRWKҩ\WӹOӋ6+112:1FyTXDQKӋQJѭӧF
FKLӅXYӟL+4.'WURQJPӭFờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
1KѭYұ\PӝWOҫQQӳDNӃWTXҧѭӟFOѭӧQJFӫQJ
FӕTXDQÿLӇP VӱGөQJP{KuQK WX\ӃQ WtQKYj
PӕLTXDQKӋJLӳD6+11Yj+4.' OjQJѭӧF
FKLӅX
9DL WUz FӫD 6+11 WURQJ ӭQJ SKy %Ĉ.+
7URQJP{ KuQK %ҧQJ KӋ Vӕ ELӃQ WѭѫQJ
WiFJLӳD6+11Yj%Ĉ.+FyWѭѫQJTXDQFQJ
FKLӅXYӟL+4.'KӋVӕFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
7KұWEҩWQJӡNKLOờWKX\ӃWYjFiFEҵQJFKӭQJ
WKӵFQJKLӋP WUѭӟFÿk\ FKR UҵQJPӕLTXDQKӋ
Qj\OjQJѭӧFFKLӅXÿӇSKҧQiQKFiFF{QJW\Fy
6+11FKҩSQKұQOӧLQKXұQWKҩSÿӇ[ӱOờFiF
YҩQÿӅOLrQTXDQÿӃQ%Ĉ.+Ӣ9LӋW1DPPӕL
TXDQKӋFӫDELӃQWѭѫQJWiFOjFQJFKLӅX3KҧL
FKăQJ FiF &73Ĉ 1Kj QѭӟF ÿm ÿѭӧF NKX\ӃQ
NKtFKWKӵFKLӋQFiFJLҧLSKiSӭQJSKy%Ĉ.+
YjQKұQÿѭӧFFiFQJXӗQKӛWUӧWӕWQKѭYӕQYD\
ѭXÿmLKD\PLӉQJLҧPFiFNKRҧQÿyQJJySQKѭ
SKtWKXӃKRһFÿѭӧF&KtQKSKӫEҧROmQKÿӇYD\
FiFQJXӗQYӕQWӯFiFWәFKӭFWjLFKtQKTXӕFWӃ
ĈLӅXQj\ OjPFKRYDL WUzFӫD1KjQѭӟF WURQJ
FiF&73Ĉӣ9LӋW1DPPDQJOҥLOӧLtFKOӟQKѫQ
9ҩQÿӅ FKL SKt ÿҥL GLӋQ7ҩW Fҧ FiF NӃW TXҧ
FKRWKҩ\WăQJFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQOjPJLҧP+4.'
FiF &73Ĉ ӣ9LӋW 1DP7URQJ %ҧQJ KӋ Vӕ
FӫDELӃQ$&Fy WѭѫQJTXDQQJѭӧFFKLӅXYӟL
+4.'WURQJPӭFờQJKƭDWKӕQJNrKӋVӕFӫD
ELӃQ$&FyWѭѫQJTXDQFQJFKLӅXYӟL+4.'
FiFKӋVӕFNJQJFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr$&WăQJ
SKҧQiQKWăQJFKLSKtKRҥWÿӝQJPjQJѭӡLÿҥL
GLӋQSKҫQYӕQ1KjQѭӟFWҥRUD$&JLҧPOҥL
43
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
%ҧQJ7әQJKӧSNӃWTXҧPӕLTXDQKӋFӫDELӃQNLӇPVRiW
677 %LӃQ .ǤYӑQJ .ӃWTXҧ
ĈzQEҭ\WjLFKtQK KRһF 7ѭѫQJ TXDQ QJKӏFK YӟL52$ WURQJPӭF ờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
7ӹOӋWKDQKWRiQKLӋQKjQK -
7ѭѫQJTXDQ WKXұQYӟL52$Yj52( WURQJ
PӭFờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
3 4X\P{F{QJW\ + 7ѭѫQJTXDQQJKӏFKYӟL52$Yj52(WURQJPӭFờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
1JX͛QW͝QJKͫSFͯDWiFJL̫
SKҧQiQKKLӋXTXҧVӱGөQJWjLVҧQNpPFӫDQKj
TXҧQWUӏÿҥLGLӋQSKҫQYӕQ1KjQѭӟF1ӃXYӕQ
6+11FDRFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQFDR WKu$& WăQJ
Yj$&JLҧP NӃW TXҧ FXӕL FQJ Oj OjPJLҧP
+4.'
%ҧQJ.ӃWTXҧѭӟFOѭӧQJP{KuQKYӟLSKѭѫQJSKiS*00
%LӃQ
.Ǥ
YӑQJ 52$ 52( 52$ 52(
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5) (6)
/
'591 +
2:1B'591
-
'791 -
2:1B'791
-
2:1 -
$& -
$& +
/(9
/,4 -
SIZE +
***
B&216
1JX͛Q7tQKWRiQFͯDWiFJL̫WͳSK̯QP͉PWK͙QJNr
O̯QO˱ͫWEL͋XWK͓PͱFờQJKƭD
WK͙QJNrYj*LiWU͓WURQJQJR̿Fÿ˯QEL͋XWK͓VDLV͙WK͙QJNr
ҦQKKѭӣQJFӫDFiFELӃQNLӇPVRiW
7ҩWFҧFiFNӃWTXҧѭӟF OѭӧQJ WURQJ%ҧQJ
FKRNӃWTXҧFKRWKҩ\JLDWăQJWӹOӋÿzQEҭ\WjL
FKtQK OjPJLҧP+4.' Wӹ OӋ WKDQK WRiQKLӋQ
KjQKWăQJOjPWăQJ+4.'YjTX\P{F{QJW\
WăQJOjPJLҧP+4.'&iFNӃWTXҧWiFÿӝQJFӫD
FiFELӃQNLӇPVRiWÿѭӧFWәQJKӧSWURQJ%ҧQJ
.ӃWTXҧNLӇPFKӭQJP{KuQK
&iF WiF ÿӝQJ FӫD %Ĉ.+ QӃX OjP JLҧP
+4.'Fy WKӇKjPờFKLSKtNLQKGRDQK WăQJ
OrQ GR%Ĉ.+&KL SKt Fy WKӇ ÿѭӧF [HP QKѭ
ELӃQVӕWUXQJJLDQÿӇNLӇPFKӭQJPӕLTXDQKӋ
JLӳ%Ĉ.+WӹOӋ6+11Yj+4.'FӫD&73Ĉ
%ҧQJ WUuQK Ej\ NӃW TXҧ FiFP{ KuQK ѭӟF
OѭӧQJ WiFÿӝQJFӫD%Ĉ.+Yj6+11ÿӃQFKL
SKtJLiYӕQKjQJEiQFӫDFiF&73Ĉ7UiLYӟL
NǤYӑQJNӃWTXҧѭӟF OѭӧQJWҥLFӝWYjFӝW
44
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
%ҧQJ7iFÿӝQJFӫD%Ĉ.+Yj6+11ÿӃQFKLSKt&73Ĉ
%LӃQ .ǤYӑQJ &25 &25
/ +
'591 -
2:1;'591 +
'791 +
2:1;'791 +
2:1 +
$& +
$& +
/(9 +
/,4 -
SIZE +
B&216
1JX͛Q7tQKWRiQFͯDWiFJL̫WͳSK̯QP͉PWK͙QJNr
O̯QO˱ͫWEL͋XWK͓PͱFờ
QJKƭDWK͙QJNrYj*LiWU͓WURQJQJR̿Fÿ˯QEL͋XWK͓VDLV͙WK͙QJNr
%ҧQJFKRWKҩ\ELӃQ'591FyWiFÿӝQJ
FQJFKLӅXYӟLFKLSKtKRҥWÿӝQJKӋVӕFKѭDFy
ờQJKƭDWKӕQJNrELӃQ'791FyWiF
ÿӝQJQJѭӧFFKLӅXYӟLFKLSKtKRҥWÿӝQJKӋVӕ
FyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr.ӃWTXҧQj\FKRWKҩ\
QӃX%Ĉ.+WKӇKLӋQTXDPѭDQKLӅXKѫQFyWKӇ
OjPFKLSKtJLiYӕQWăQJWURQJNKLQKLӋWÿӝFDR
KѫQ FKL SKt JLi YӕQJLҧP&y WKӇ Yu NKLPѭD
QKLӅXFiFFKLSKtOLrQTXDQÿӃQEҧRGѭӥQJKӗ
ÿұSÿѭӡQJWUX\ӅQKRһFSKҧL[ҧONJQrQFKLSKt
JLiYӕQWăQJYjRQKӳQJQăPPѭDQKLӅX7URQJ
NKLÿyQKѭQJQăPtWPѭDQKLӋWÿӝWUXQJEuQK
FDRFiFFKLSKtQj\ tWKѫQQrQJySSKҫQ OjP
JLҧPJLiYӕQ
%ҧQJFNJQJFKRWKҩ\6+11FyWѭѫQJTXDQ
QJѭӧFFKLӅXYӟLJLiYӕQKӋVӕFKѭDFyờQJKƭD
WKӕQJNr7ҩWFҧFiFNӃWTXҧFKRWKҩ\FKLSKtÿҥL
GLӋQ$&Yj$&FyWiFÿӝQJFQJFKLӅXÿӃQ
JLiYӕQ7ҩWFҧFiFKӋVӕÿӅXFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJ
Nr.ӃWTXҧQj\FӫQJFӕTXDQÿLӇPFKtSKt
ÿҥLGLӋQWăQJGR6+11WăQJOjPWăQJFKLSKt
cho &73Ĉ
%LӃQWѭѫQJWiFJLӳDWӹOӋVӣKӳXYj%Ĉ.+WҥL
FӝWYjFyWѭѫQJTXDQFQJFKLӅXYӟLJLi
YӕQKӋVӕFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNrYj.ӃW
TXҧQj\FKRELӃWFiFF{QJW\Fy6+11FDRNKL
%Ĉ.+WăQJOrQJLiYӕQFNJQJWăQJOѫQKѫQ&y
WKӇYuSKҧLWKӵFKLӋQFiFELӋQSKiSÿӇNLӇPVRiW
%Ĉ.+QrQ FKL SKt VҧQ [XҩW FNJQJ Yu WKӃ WăQJ
cao.
1ӃXVRYӟLNӃWTXҧSKҫQGӉQKұQUDUҵQJ
ELӃQWѭѫQJWiFOjPWăQJOӧLQKXұQYjOjPWăQJ
JLiYӕQFKRFiF&73Ĉ.ӃWTXҧQj\SKKӧS
YӟL JLҧL WKtFK FiF F{QJ W\ Fy6+11NKL WKӵF
KLӋQFiFELӋQSKiSӭQJSKyYӟL%Ĉ.+VӁOjP
WăQJJLiYӕQQKѭQJEOҥLFyWKӇF{QJW\ÿѭӧF
QKұQOҥLFiFKӛWUӧNKiFQKѭÿѭӧFWLӃSFұQFiF
QJXӗQYӕQYD\ѭXÿmLKD\ÿѭӧFѭXÿmLYӅÿҩW
ÿDLÿӇSKөFYөVҧQ[XҩWNLQKGRDQKKRһFÿѭӧF
KѭӣQJFiFOӧLtFKNKiFQJRjLKRҥWÿӝQJVҧQ[XҩW
FKtQKQKѭÿѭӧFJySYӕQYjRFiFF{QJW\FXQJ
FҩS FiF GӏFK Yө Kӛ WUӧ VҧQ [XҩW F{QJ QJKLӋS
WKLӃWEӏÿLӋQô
&XӕLFQJ%ҧQJFKRWKҩ\YD\QӧQKLӅXYj
TX\P{F{QJW\OӟQKѫQVӁOjPFKRFKLSKtWăQJ
OrQ&iFKӋVӕWURQJFiFWUѭӡQJKӧSQj\ÿӅXFy
ờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr0ӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDWӹOӋWKDQK
WRiQKLӋQKjQKYjJLiYӕQOjFQJFKLӅXQKѭQJ
KӋVӕFKѭDFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
45
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
&iFNӃWOXұQ
4XD SKkQ WtFK WKӵF QJKLӋS Wӯ Gӳ OLӋX
%&7&&73Ĉӣ9LӋW1DP&iF NӃW
TXҧ WURQJP{KuQK WX\ӃQ WtQKFKR WKҩ\
%Ĉ.+Fy WiFÿӝQJÿӃQ+4.'YjFKL
SKtJLiYӕQFӫD&73Ĉ1ӃX%Ĉ.+ÿR
OѭӡQJEҵQJFKrQKOӋFKOѭӧQJPѭDWUXQJ
EuQKQăPVRYӟLQKӳQJQăPNӃW
TXҧFKRWKҩ\%Ĉ.+WăQJOjP?+4.'
QKѭQJKӋVӕFKѭDFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
1ӃX%Ĉ.+ÿR OѭӡQJEҵQJFKrQK OӋFK
QKLӋW ÿӝ KҵQJ QăP VR YӟL WUXQJ EuQK
QKӳQJ QăP NӃW TXҧ FKR WKҩ\
%Ĉ.+OjPJLҧP+4.'FiFKӋVӕFyờ
QJKƭDWKӕQJNr
.KLSKkQWtFKWiFÿӝQJFӫD%Ĉ.+ÿӃQ
JLi YӕQ KjQJ EiQ &73Ĉ NӃW TXҧ ѭӟF
OѭӧQJ FKR WKҩ\1ӃX%Ĉ.+ÿR OѭӡQJ
EҵQJFKrQKOӋFKOѭӧQJPѭDWUXQJEuQK
QăP VR YӟL QKӳQJ QăP NӃW TXҧ
%Ĉ.+FyWiFÿӝQJFQJFKLӅXYӟLFKL
SKtKRҥWÿӝQJKӋ Vӕ FyờQJKƭD WKӕQJ
Nr 1ӃX %Ĉ.+ ÿR OѭӡQJ EҵQJ FKrQK
OӋFK QKLӋW ÿӝ KҵQJ QăP VR YӟL WUXQJ
EuQKQKӳQJQăPNӃWTXҧ%Ĉ.+
FyWiFÿӝQJQJѭӧFFKLӅXYӟLFKLSKtKRҥW
ÿӝQJKӋVӕFNJQJFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
M{ KuQK WKӵF QJKLӋP FKR WKҩ\ Wӹ OӋ
6+11 FDR OjP JLҧP+4.'.ӃW TXҧ
WѭѫQJ Wӵ NKL SKkQ WtFK WiF ÿӝQJ FӫD
6+11WK{QJTXDELӃQFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQ
7ҩW Fҧ FiFKӋ Vӕ WURQJFiF WUѭӡQJKӧS
ÿӅXFyờQJKƭDWKӕQJNr
.KL [HP [pW YDL WUz FӫD 6+11 WURQJ
NLӇPVRiW%Ĉ.+P{KuQKÿmVӱGөQJ
NӻWKXұWELӃQWѭѫQJWiFNӃWTXҧFKRWKҩ\
ELӃQ WѭѫQJ WiF OjP WăQJ OӧL QKXұQ Yj
OjPWăQJJLiYӕQFKRFiF&73Ĉ1JKƭD
Oj6+11FDRÿLFQJYӟL%Ĉ.+JL~S
FiF&73ĈFyPӭFVLQKOӡLFDRKѫQPһF
GFKLSKtFyWăQJKѫQ
.ӃWTXҧQJKLrQFӭXFNJQJ WuPWKҩ\YD\
QӧQKLӅXYjTX\P{OӟQKѫQOjPJLҧP
+4.'FӫD&73Ĉ
&iFNKX\ӃQQJKӏ
%Ĉ.+ÿDQJGLӉQUDYjWiFÿӝQJWUӵFWLӃS
ÿӃQ+4.'FiF&73ĈFiFKLӋQ WѭӧQJ
PѭD QKLӅX Yj KҥQ KiQ Fy WKӇ ÿDQ [HQ
TXDFiFQăP&iFWiFÿӝQJFӫD%Ĉ.+
ÿӃQ+4.'FNJQJWKD\ÿәLW\WKHRELӇX
KLӋQ OjPѭDQKLӅXKD\KҥQKiQĈӇәQ
ÿӏQK Yj WăQJ+4.' FiF QKj TXҧQ WUӏ
&73ĈQrQFyNӃKRҥFKӭQJSKyQKѭVӱ
GөQJFiFNӻ WKXұWPӟL WURQJ[k\GӵQJ
Kӗ ÿұS WURQJ [k\ GӵQJ Fѫ Vӣ Kҥ WҫQJ
WUX\ӅQWҧLÿLӋQô7ұQGөQJFiFFѫKӝL
Kӛ WUӧFӫD&KtQKSKӫÿӇ WKӵFKLӋQFiF
JLҧLSKiSӭQJSKyYӟL%Ĉ.+
6+11FDROjPJLҧP+4.'QKѭQJOҥL
JL~SOjPJLҧPWiFÿӝQJ[ҩXFӫD%Ĉ.+
ÿӃQ +4.' FӫD &73Ĉ 'R Yұ\ NKL
&KtQKSKӫJLҧPWӹOӋ6+11ӣFiFF{QJ
W\ FҫQ Fy FiF JLҧL SKiS Kӛ WUӧ ÿӇ FiF
F{QJW\FyWKӇWKӵFKLӋQFiFELӋQSKiS
ӭQJSKyYӟL%Ĉ.+7X\QKLrQFiFELӋQ
SKiSKӛWUӧFҫQF{QJEҵQJYjPLQKEҥFK
ÿӇ FiF GRDQK QJKLӋS Wѭ QKkQ FNJQJ Fy
WKӇKѭӣQJFiFѭXÿmLKD\KӛWUӧQKѭFiF
.ӃWOXұQYjNKX\ӃQQJKӏ
46
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
7jLOLӋXWKDPNKҧR
7LӃQJ$QK
$QJ-&ROH5/LQ-$JHQF\costs and ownership structure. -RXUQDORI)LQDQFH
±
$UHOODQR0 %RYHU2$QRWKHU/RRNat the Instrumental-Variable Estimation
of Error-Components Models. -RXUQDORI(FRQRPHWULFV
$UHOODQR0%RQG506RPHWHVWRIVSHFL¿FDWLRQIRUSDQHOGDWD0RQWH&DUOR
HYLGHQFHDQGDSSOLFDWLRQWRHPSOR\PHQWHTXDWLRQV5HYLHZRI(FRQRPLFV6WXGLHV
%HQHVWDG5DVPXV+HDWLQJGHJUHHGD\VFRROLQJGHJUHHGD\VDQGSUHFLSLWDWLRQLQ
(XURSHDQDO\VLVIRUWKH&(/(&7SURMHFW5HSRUWIRU1RUZHJLDQPHW,QVWLWXWHDYDLODEOHRQOLQHDW
KWWSPHWQR)RUVNQLQJ3XEOLNDVMRQHUPHWQRBUHSRUW¿OHVWRUHPHWQRBSGI
&Oz6)HUUDULV0DQG)ORULR02ZQHUVKLSand environmental regulation: Evi-
dence from the European electricity industry. (QHUJ\(FRQRPLFV±
&RQVLGLQH7-0DUNXSSULFLQJLQDVKRUWUXQPRGHOZLWKLQYHQWRULHV,QWHUQDWLRQDO
6RFLHW\IRU,QYHQWRU\5HVHDUFK,QYLWHGSDSHU,Q$66$0HHWLQJVLQ%RVWRQ0$-DQXDU\
'HPHUV'DQG5R\5,PSDFWVRIFOLPDWHFKDQJHRQDK\GURORJLFDOUHJLPHDQGHI-
IHFWVRQK\GURHOHFWULFLW\SURGXFWLRQLQWKHSURYLQFHRI4XHEHF&DQDGD,Q(XURSHDQ&RQIHUHQFH
on Impacts of Climate Change on Renewable Energy Sources, Iceland, June;
(OHIWKHULDGLV, $QDJQRVWRSRXORX('LDYDVWLV,DQG.RQVWDQWLQRV$&5H-
ODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQ)LQDQFLDO3HUIRUPDQFHDQG&RUSRUDWH'LVFORVXUHVUHJDUGLQJ&OLPDWH&KDQJH
Practices. &RQIHUHQFH &RQIHUHQFH WK ,QWHUQDWLRQDO &RQIHUHQFH RQ$FFRXQWLQJ DQG )LQDQFH.
'2,
+DPLOWRQ-73ROOXWLRQas news: Media DQGVWRFNPDUNHWUHDFWLRQVWRWKHWR[LFV
release inventory data. -RXUQDORI(QYLURQPHQWDO(FRQRPLFVDQG0DQDJHPHQW
,3&&&URVV&XWWLQJ,QYHVWPHQWDQG)LQDQFHIssues, 0LWLJDWLRQRI&OLPDWH&KDQJH
:*,,,&RQWULEXWLRQWRWKH)LIWK$VVHVVPHQW5HSRUW&83
,ZDWD+DQG.2NDGD+RZ'RHV(QYLURQPHQWDO3HUIRUPDQFH$IIHFW)LQDQFLDO
Performance? (FRORJLFDO(FRQRPLFV±
.KaQQD0:4XLPLRDQG'%RMLORYD7R[LF5HOHDVH,QIRUPDWLRQDpolicy tool
for environmental information. -RXUQDORI(QYLURQPHQWDO(FRQRPLFVDQG0DQDJHPHQW
F{QJW\ÿDQJFy6+11
&KL SKt ÿҥL GLӋQ ÿDQJ Oj JiQK QһQJ FKR
&73ĈGRYұ\&KtQKSKӫFҫQFyFiFELӋQSKiS
NLӇPWUDJLiPViWÿӇJLҧPFKLSKtÿҥLGLӋQWҥL
FiFF{QJW\FyWӹOӋVӣKӳXFDR
47
7ҥSFKt1JKLrQFӭX7jLFKtQK0DUNHWLQJVӕ
.ODVVHQ5'and C30F/DXJKOLQ7KH,PSDFWRI(QYLURQPHQWDO0DQDJHPHQWRQ
Firm Performance. 0DQDJHPHQW6FLHQFH±
/LX<DQG.RNNR$:LQG3RZHULQ&KLQD3ROLF\DQG'HYHORSPHQW&KDOOHQJHV
(QHUJ\3ROLF\
0D\HU%HQRLWDQG5DMDYXRUL0LNNR6WDWH2ZQHUVKLSDQG&OLPDWH&KDQJH0LWLJD-
WLRQ2YHUFRPLQJWKH&DUERQ&XUVH"&OLPDWHDQG&DUERQ/DZ5HYLHZ)RUWKFRPLQJ$YDLODEOH
DW6651KWWSVVUQFRPDEVWUDFW
6LQJK0 'DYLGVRQ,,,:1Agency costs, ownership structure and corporate
governance mechanisms. -RXUQDORI%DQNLQJ )LQDQFH±
9LWKHVVRQWKLD& 7RQJXUDL-7KHHIIHFWRI¿UPVL]HRQWKHOHYHUDJH±SHUIRUPDQFH
UHODWLRQVKLSGXULQJWKH¿QDQFLDOFULVLVRI±-RXUQDORI0XOWLQDWLRQDO)LQDQFLDO0DQD
JHPHQW±
:DQJ<- /LTXLGLW\PDQDJHPHQWRSHUDWLQJSHUIRUPDQFH DQGFRUSRUDWHYDOXH
evidence from Japan and Taiwan. -RXUQDORI0XOWLQDWLRQDO)LQDQFLDO0DQDJHPHQW
7LӃQJ9LӋW
1JX\ӉQ4XӕF1JKLYj0DL9ăQ1DP&iFQKkQWӕҧQKKѭӣQJÿӃQKLӋXTXҧKRҥW
ÿӝQJNLQKGRDQKFӫDGRDQKQJKLӋSQKӓYjYӯDӣ7KjQK3Kӕ&ҫQ7Kѫ7ҥSFKt.KRDKӑFE
ĈRjQ9LQK7KăQJ0ӕLTXDQKӋJLӳDFҩXWU~FYӕQYjKLӋXTXҧNLQKGRDQK9DLWUz
WѭѫQJWiFFӫDVӣKӳXQKjQѭӟF7̩SFKt.KRDK͕FĈ̩LK͕F$Q*LDQJVӕWUDQJ
1JX\ӉQ9ăQ7KҳQJYjFiFWiFJLҧNKiF%LӃQÿәLNKtKұXYjWiFÿӝQJӣ9LӋW1DP
9L͏QNKRDK͕FNKtW˱ͫQJWKͯ\YăQYjP{LWU˱ͥQJ+j1ӝL±
9};XkQ9LQK&ҩXWU~FVӣKӳXKLӋXTXҧKRҥWÿӝQJYjJLiWUӏGRDQKQJKLӋSWUrQWKӏ
WUѭӡQJFKӭQJNKRiQ9LӋW1DP3KiW7ULӇQ +ӝL1KұS6ӕ7KiQJ
%ӝ7jL1JX\rQYj0{L7UѭӡQJ&KѭѫQJWUuQKPөFWLrXTXӕFJLDӭQJSKyYӟLELӃQ
ÿәLNKtKұX7KiQJ;
4X\ӃWÿӏQKVӕ4Ĉ77*QJj\FӫD7KӫWѭӟQJ&KtQKSKӫ3KrGX\ӋW&KLӃQ
OѭӧFTXӕFJLDYӅELӃQÿәLNKtKұX
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
- 12_8101_2141143.pdf