Tài liệu A research on bone mineral density in the hip joint and evaluation on intertrochanteric fracture treatment with bipolar joint hip replacement in the elderly from 2012 to 2015 at 103 military hospital – Le Ngoc Hai: Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
134
A RESEARCH ON BONE MINERAL DENSITY IN THE HIP JOINT
AND EVALUATION ON INTERTROCHANTERIC FRACTURE
TREATMENT WITH BIPOLAR JOINT HIP REPLACEMENT IN THE
ELDERLY FROM 2012 TO 2015 AT 103 MILITARY HOSPITAL
Le Ngoc Hai1; Tran Dinh Chien2
SUMMARY
Objectives: To investigate hip osteoporosis among elderly patients with intertrochanteric and
to evaluate the outcome of fracture treatment with bipolar joint replacement in the elderly.
Subjects and methods: A retrospective and prospective study on 60 patients (15 men and 45
women), mean age 82.62 ± 5.75 (from 70 to 102 years old) were treated for hip fracture with hip
replacement partially used cement at 103 Military Hospital from 09 - 2012 to 12 - 2015. Clinical
description of age, gender, lesion characteristics, bone mineral density in the hip and immediate
and predicted results. Results and conclusions: Age group 80 - 89 accouted for 48.33%,
women/men ratio 3.0...
8 trang |
Chia sẻ: Đình Chiến | Ngày: 06/07/2023 | Lượt xem: 358 | Lượt tải: 0
Bạn đang xem nội dung tài liệu A research on bone mineral density in the hip joint and evaluation on intertrochanteric fracture treatment with bipolar joint hip replacement in the elderly from 2012 to 2015 at 103 military hospital – Le Ngoc Hai, để tải tài liệu về máy bạn click vào nút DOWNLOAD ở trên
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
134
A RESEARCH ON BONE MINERAL DENSITY IN THE HIP JOINT
AND EVALUATION ON INTERTROCHANTERIC FRACTURE
TREATMENT WITH BIPOLAR JOINT HIP REPLACEMENT IN THE
ELDERLY FROM 2012 TO 2015 AT 103 MILITARY HOSPITAL
Le Ngoc Hai1; Tran Dinh Chien2
SUMMARY
Objectives: To investigate hip osteoporosis among elderly patients with intertrochanteric and
to evaluate the outcome of fracture treatment with bipolar joint replacement in the elderly.
Subjects and methods: A retrospective and prospective study on 60 patients (15 men and 45
women), mean age 82.62 ± 5.75 (from 70 to 102 years old) were treated for hip fracture with hip
replacement partially used cement at 103 Military Hospital from 09 - 2012 to 12 - 2015. Clinical
description of age, gender, lesion characteristics, bone mineral density in the hip and immediate
and predicted results. Results and conclusions: Age group 80 - 89 accouted for 48.33%,
women/men ratio 3.0/1. Classified based on AO, group A2 made up 63.33%. Bone mineral
density measured in accordance with DEXA was 60 patients: BMI index 18.5 - 22.9 accounted
for 73.33%, Singh highest grade 55.0%, T-score average femur neck -3.62 ± 0.55, T-score =
-3.9 for majority, T-score for femoral neck -3.03 ± 0.44; T-score average intertrochanteric
fracture -3.02 ± 0.4; mean T-score of Ward area -3.91 ± 0.58; T-score mean head-to-hip ratio
-3.20 ± 0.53. Bone mineral density of the neck - trochanteric - intertrochanteric - total head on
the male thigh bone was significantly higher than that of females (p < 0.05); However, Ward's
triangle bone between two groups of males and females was not different (p = 0.18487).
Immediate evaluation: 100%, distance scale results according to Merle D’Aubigné - Postel: very
good: 10.0%, good: 53.33%, quite: 23.33%, medium: 8.33%, bad: 5.0%.
* Keywords: Intertrochanteric; Bipolar; Elderly; Hip replacemen; DEXA.
INTRODUCTION
Intertrochanteric hip fracture among
the elderly is very common. Women
outnumber men, due to the common
cause of falls. In the United States, it is
expected that 200,000 patients suffer
from hip fractures usually with mortality
up to 15 - 30%, commonly found in
patients older than 70 years, whose
treatment is up to $10 bil per year [5].
Intertrochanteric fracture is painful,
even more traumatic specifically in the
elderly treatment due to the elderly‘s
fracture complexity, poor bone quality and
chronic systemic combination. Many methods
of treatment of intertrochanteric fractures
have been studied and applied such as
bone grafts with DHS splint, braces, nails
Gamma have brought good results.
However, in cases of unstable fractures,
1. Thanhhoa Department of Health
2. 103 Military Hospital
Corresponding author: Le Ngoc Hai (phhaingoai@gmail.com)
Date received: 11/06/2018
Date accepted: 19/11/2018
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
135
broken bones, or thinning of the bones,
bone grading methods are ineffective for
the patients who are unable to bone slow
recovery, ill hip joint, limiting the rapid
recovery, making the patients unable to
move early. In these cases, many authors
advocate partial hip replacement for the
purpose of helping patients quickly to
restore their movement or even to sit up
early. This approach helps avoiding
systemic complications due to long-term
restlessness including ulceration, pneumonia,
or other systemic diseases.
In Vietnam in recent years, many hip
replacement surgery clinics have applied
partial hip replacement on the elderly patients
with intertrochanteric fractures. However, no
agreement on this issue has been reached
and no study has evaluated osteoporosis
in the elderly patients with intertrochanteric
fractures. Therefore, we have conducted
a study on the topic with the goal:
- To review osteoporosis in the hip of
associated with intertrochanteric fracture.
- To evaluate bipolar partial hip
replacement in the elderly patients with
intertrochanteric fracture.
SUBJECTS AND METHODS
1. Subjects.
- 60 patients aged 70 years old and
above, regardless of sex, intertrochanteric
fractured type A1, A2, A3 by AO
classification, Singh grade 1 - 2 - 3
osteoporosis according to Singh, bipolar
surgery with cement at 103 Military
Hospital from 09 - 2012 to 12 - 2015
provided with accompanied documents:
Full medical records, with pre-
operative, postoperative and scheduled
screening. Bone mineral density in the hip
based DEXA surgery were measured and
recorded.
- All 60 patients with the first time of
hip replacement, with the mortar in good
condition, not degraded, not deformed.
2. Methods.
- Retrospective and prospective study,
clinical description.
Reseach categories include: Age, sex,
traumatic features, bone density survey,
indicative draw and studies of treatment
results: Evaluation of the close results:
Closeness of wound rehabilitation of hip
joint and the complications of premature
and complete onset. Outcome evaluation:
According to Merle D'Aubigné - Postel:
17 - 18 points: excellents; 15 - 16 points:
good; 13 - 14 points: quite; 10 - 12 points:
medium; ≤ 9 points: bad.
* Data processing: Processed on
Epi.info 7 software.
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
136
RESULTS
1. Classification of intertrochanteric fracture based on age, gender in
elderly patients.
Table 1: Age, gender (n = 60).
Gender
Age
Men
Women
Total
Percentage %
70 - 79 years old 7 14 21 35.0
80 - 89 years old 6 23 29 48.33
> 90 years old 2 8 10 16.67
Total 15 45 60
Percentage % 25.0 75.0
100
The age group of 80 - 89 accounted for the highest proportion (48.33%);
women/men ratio: 3.0/1.
Causes of fracture: 2 cases of traffic accident accounted for 3.33%, falls: 58 cases
(96.67%); intertrochanteric fracture alone was 58 patients, with two patients with
forearm fractures and software lesions.
Table 2: Classification of intertrochanteric fractures by AO (n = 60).
AO
Age A1 A2 Total
Percentage
%
70 - 79 years old 9 12 21 35.0%
80 - 89 years old 11 18 29 48.33%
≥ 90 years old 2 8 10 16.67%
Total 22 38 60 100.0%
Percentage % 36.67% 63.33%
Intertrochanteric fracture was rated by category AO with the highest percentage of
63.33% in A2 fracture, the age group of 80 - 89 had 29 patients (48.33%) in which A2
was present in 18 patients.
Table 3: Measurement of bone mineral density of intertrochanteric fracture to Singh
(n = 60).
Osteoporosis
Age Grade I Grade II Grade III Total
Percentage
%
70 - 79 years old 0 13 8 21 35.0%
80 - 89 years old 5 19 5 29 48.33%
≥ 90 years old 9 1 0 10 16.67%
Total 14 33 13 60 100.0%
Percentage % 23.33 55.0 21.67
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
137
Among 3 grades of osteoporosis, grade II accounted for the highest percentage
(55.0%). Out of the three groups of age, the group aged 80 - 89 made up the highest
percentage (48.33%). Compared to male, females aged more vulnerable to osteoporosis.
- Systemic combined disease: There was no systemic disease: 20 patients
(33.33%), cardiovascular disease, blood pressure: 31 patients (51.67%), diabetes:
5 patients (5.0%), others: 6 patients (10.0%).
Table 4: Osteoporosis level in patients with intertrochanteric fractures with age (n = 60).
Gender
Variable
Male
(n = 15)
Female
(n = 45) Note
Neck 0.54 ± 0.05 0.48 ± 0.07 p = 0.00346
Troch 0.50 ± 0.05 0.45 ± 0.07 p = 0.00950
Inter 0.74 ± 0.21 0.61 ± 0.16 p = 0.01498
Ward’s 0.29 ± 0.09 0.28 ± 0.08 p = 0.83085
BMD (g/cm2)
Total 0.64 ± 0.16 0.54 ± 0.14 p = 0.01505
Neck -3.42± 0.50 -3.68±0.56 p = 0.11739
Troch -2.88 ± 0.30 -3.08±0.47 p = 0.12216
Inter -2.8 ± 0.25 -3.1 ±0.42 p = 0.01069
Ward’s -3.75 ± 0.47 -3.98±0.61 p = 0.18487
T-score
Total -2.95±0.30 -3.27 ±0.56 p = 0.04130
A research on bone density in the hip
area revealed a decrease in bone density
among 60 patients of hip bone fracture
with DEXA technique, compared to the
mean bone density in the femoral head.
However, the comparison between the
genders showed that women's osteoporosis
level was higher than that of men with
difference from p = 0.01069 < 0.05.
Comparison of mean hip osteoporosis
on the femur with the corresponding
Singh score: Grade 1/grade 2/grade 3:
mean T-score -3.26 ± 0.47/-3.02 ± 0.38/
-2.78 ± 0.19, respectively, correlated well
with Singh-singularity, the difference
between the level of significance and
p = 0.00710 was statistically significant.
2. Treatment results.
* Review immediate results:
First dry scalp 60 patients (100%),
early X-ray results after surgery 100.0%
of the following artificial joint replacement
in the right place, with no dislocated
or semi-located joint. Average postoperative
objective exercises were 2.95 ± 0.47 days
after surgery, postoperative subjective
exercises from 5.32 ± 0.65 days, mean
hospital stay after surgery was 8.02 ±
2.55 days.
* Outcome evaluation:
During the follow-up from 4 months to
40 months on 60 patients, which mainly
falls on the follow-up duration of 36 months,
X-ray after surgery shows 100% joint still
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
138
in position. The patients had tendency
to be able to move at the highest
frequency of fold/stretch/format/fit/ rotate
in/offset were: 100 degrees/5 degrees/
45 degrees/25 degrees/40 degrees/
40 degrees.
* Evaluation based on the Merle
D'Postel scale:
Very good: 6 patients (10.0%); good:
32 patients (53.33%); quite: 14 patients
(23.33%); medium: 5 patients (8.33%);
bad: 3 patients (5.0%).
DISCUSSION
1. Characteristics of intertrochanteric fractures of the elderly.
Table 5: Comparison of patient characteristics with other authors.
Author Proportion of women/men The average age
Tran Manh Hung et al (2014) [1] 2.3/1 81.8 (70 - 94)
Hoang The Hung (2013) [2] 2.8/1 82.19 ± 4.8 (72 - 95)
Nguyen Manh Khanh (2012) [3] 3.3/1 78.9 (70 - 97)
Joong-Myung Lee (2011) [6] 2.6/1 78.3 (64 - 95)
Zhang Q et al (2005) [7] 1.25/1 72 - 91
Laffosse JM et al (2007) [8] 3.8/1 81.1 (70 - 91)
We (2015) 3.0/1 82.62 ± 5.75 (70 - 102)
In 60 patients, the lowest was 70 years
old, the highest was 102 years old. The
mean age was 82.62 ± 5.74. The age
group of 80 - 89 accounted for the highest
percentage (48.33%). Men accounted for
25.0%, women accounted for 75.0%.
Women/men ratio 3.0/1. We found that
there was no considerable difference
between our results and other domestic
and foreign authors’ findings in terms of
the age of patients who had the joint
replacement and the proportion of
women/men.
The proportion of intertrochanteric
fracture in women is higher compared to
men, as the level of osteoporosis
increased, the bone quality decreased
over time and the rate of high long life
expectancy in females was higher than
that of meles [9]. Our study found that
Singh's grade II osteoporosis had the
highest proportion (33/60 patients = 55.0%),
which is more common in the age group
of 80 - 89 years old and in females than
males. Bone mineral density measured by
DEXA method were in 60/60: BMI 18.5 - 22.9
accounted for 73.33%, T-score average
femur neckline -3.62 ± 0.55, T-score =
-3.9 for the majority, T-score for femoral
neck -3.03 ± 0.44; T-score average
Intertrochanteric fractured -3.02 ± 0.4;
Mean T-score of Ward area -3.91 ± 0.58;
T-score mean head-to-hip ratio -3.2 ± 0.53.
BMD of the neck-capillary-transitional-total
head on the male thigh bone was
significantly higher than that of females
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
139
(p < 0.05); the Ward's difference in bone
density was not significantly different (p =
0.18487). On the DEXA measurement, the
BMD mass was reduced by age group:
0.66 ± 0.14/0.55 ± 0.12/0.43 ± 0.12 g/cm2,
severe osteoporosis according to T-score
of the age group: -3.12 ± 0.46/-3.17 ±
0.56/-3.41 ± 0.50. According to Ho Pham
Thuc Lan, the incidence of femoral neck
BMD in the 70+ and 20-30 age groups is
also higher in women (25%) than men
(13%) [4]. This is consistent with the
aging process of the body over time; in
the cases of the older women and men,
the estrogen (women) but age (men)
levels cause the reduction of calcium
biosynthesis, making the elderly-vulnerable
to external forces [4].
This is consistent with the mechanism
of subluxation or sagging in the elderly
mainly due to a fall in the foot slips. In our
study on 58 cases of falling, 2 cases
suffered from due to traffic accidents,
which is different from Kumar’s study with
75% of falling at a height and 25% of
traffic accidents [9].
2. Surgery comment.
According to Kumar. K [9], complexity
of intertrochanteric fractures in elderly
osteoporotic patients poses challenging
problems, with an increasing risk of
morbidity and mortality. Although union
rates as high as 100% have been reported
in association with well-reduced, stable
fractures that were treated with ideal
implant placements, failure rates of as
high as 56% have been noted in
association with unstable fractures,
comminutions, suboptimal fracture
fixations, or poor bone qualities in elderly
patients. Although the internal fixation of
such fractures may reduce the morbidity
of pain, it does not permit an early
mobilization with a fear of failure of
fixation and thus, indirectly, the morbidity
of fracture remains the same. Bipolar hip
replacement surgery should be based
on factors as: Bone condition, bone
morphology, type fracture classified
based on AO, surgeons joint replacement
experience, equipment, anesthesia
resuscitation, kit and economic condition
of patients.
According to our study, the incidence
of intertrochanteric fractures according to
the AO classification was high in A2
(63.33%) and the number of patients with
A2 fractures in 80 - 89 years old was
18 patients. Osteoporosis II and III were
76.67%. With such patients we chose
bipolar with cement, as this technique
provides a more stable fixation, especially
in case of AO breakdown A2, avoid
secondary misalignment. In the cases of
complicated fracture, we use Kirchner
screws through the large wires, using a
tightening of the 8-wire strings.
Postoperative pain relief is better,
allowing early movement, without the
complications of superinfection lung,
uremia, ulceration of the knee due to long
lying. This conclusion is consistent with
other authors’ findings [1, 7, 9].
Elderly people commonly suffer from
cardiovascular disease, hypertension and
other systemic diseases, so they need to
be examined carefully before surgery,
according to the study of bipolar
operation, it can be seen the propotion
among groups as follows: No systemic
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
140
disease: 20 patients, cardiovascular
disease, blood pressure: 31 patients
(51.67%), diabetes: 3 patients (5.0%),
other diseases: 6 patients (10.0%). All
cases have been treated before surgery.
3. Evaluation of treatment results.
* The short-term results:
Dry scalp, right in the first treatment
were found 60/60 patients (100%).
Immediate X-ray results after surgery
showed that 100% of artificial joints were
in the right position, cases of dislocated or
half-dislocated joint. No complications in
surgery occured. Only one case of
cerebral stroke after 4 days of surgery
was detected promptly and treatment is
stable before the patient’s discharge.
Patients were instructed to exercise
passively from day 2 after surgery (2.95 ±
0.47 days), active training from day 4,
medium from 5.32 ± 0.65 days, slight
incision. Other authors’ findings [2, 6, 10]
suggested that rapid rehabilitation after
treatment due to joint activity and
exercise, reduces overall complications
intertrochanteric fracture caused.
* Follow-up results:
The follow-up of 60 patients after
surgery ranged from 4 months to 40 months,
average 22.82 ± 10.15 months, the
number of 36 month follow-up patients
accounted for the highest rate,
prostoperative X-ray surgery shows 100%
in the right position without any cases of
dislocation.
Merle D'Postel: very good: 10.0%,
good: 53.33%, quite: 23.33%, medium:
8.33%, bad: 5.0%.
Our follow-up period was longer than
that of Hoang The Hung [2], where
average follow-up time was 16.17 ± 10.86
months with excellent results 37.1%,
good 42.9%, fair 17.1%, bad 2.9%.
According to Joong-Myung Lee et al,
32 out of 41 patients (78%) recovered
walking ability.
CONCLUSION
According to a study of 60 high-risk
fractured hip fracture patients with bipolar
with cement at 103 Military Hospital from
September 2012 to December 2015, we
conclude that:
- Bone mineral density survey: 60/60
bone mineral density survey. DEXA
technique showed that all patients had
osteoporosis in femoral neck,
osteoporosis levels in women were higher
than in men with a difference of p =
0.04130 < 0.05.
Comparison of mean hip osteoporosis
on DEXA females with Singh score:
Grade 1/grade 2/grade 3: average
T-score -3.39 ± 0.50/-3.24 ± 0.53/-2.83 ±
0.36, respectively, correlated well with
Singh-singularity, the difference between
the level of significance and p = 0.01425
was statistically significant.
- Evaluation of partial hip replacement
in patients with intertrochanteric fracture:
+ Personal and traumatic features:
Age from 70 to 102 years (mean 82.62
± 5.75). Age from 80 to 89 was the
highest (48.33%). Women/men ratio
3.0/1. Class A2 was the high rate
(63.33%), A2 fracture in the age of 80 - 89
was 18 patients. Osteoporosis II, III was
76.67%.
Journal of military pharmaco-medicine n
0
9-2018
141
+ Specification review:
Bipolar has cement for fixation of
firmer joints with intertrochanteric
fractures of the elderly, osteoporosis. This
helped the patients to move early, in
which the average postoperative active
exercise was 5.32 ± 0.65 days after
surgery. The treatment provided better
pain relief, reducing hospital stay to 8.02
± 2.55 days, which enabled the patients
rapidly rehabilitate, thus improving the
quality of life.
- Surgical results:
+ 100% incision in the first period.
Patients are instructed to exercise after
surgery soon.
+ Excellent: 10.0%, good: 53.33%, fair:
23.33%, medium: 8.33%, bad: 5.0%.
REFERENCES
1. Tran Manh Hung, Tran Trung Dung.
Evaluation of partial hip replacement surgery
for hip fracture in elderly patients. Journal of
Military Medicine. 2014, 295 (1 - 2).
2. Hoang The Hung. Evaluation of treatment
intertrochanteric fracture in the elderly by joint
hip replacement bipolar at 103 Military Hospital.
2013.
3. Nguyen Manh Khanh. Partial replacement
in patients with broken fractures is unstable.
Journal of Orthopedics. 2012, pp.35-38.
4. Ho Pham Thuc Lan et al. Diagnosing
osteoporosis: The impact of reference value.
Medical Journal. 2011, Vol. 01 & 02, No. 57,
pp.3-11.
5. David G, LaVelle. Fractures and
dislocations of the hip in Cammpbell's
Operative Orthopaedics. 2007, 11th ed,
Eleventh, Ed., USA, MOSBY ELSEVIER,
pp.3237-3296.
6. Joong-Myung Lee, Hee-Tae Nam,
Sang-Hun Lee. Bipolar hemiarthroplasty with
cementless femoral stem for unstable
intertrochanteric fractures. Original Article J
Korean Orthop Assoc. 2012, Vol. 47, No. 2,
pp.79-85.
7. Zhang Q, Pang Q, Huang T, Ge Z, Tang
T, Chen L. The clinical effect of bipolar long-
stem prosthetic replacement on the treatment
of comminuted intertrochanteric fracture of hip
in the elderly osteoporotic patients. Chinese
Journal of Reparative and Reconstrutive
Surgery. 2005, Vol. 19, No. 3, pp.198-200.
8. Laffosse J.M, Molinier F, Tricoire J.L,
Bonnevialle N, Chiron P, Puget J. Cementless
modular hip arthroplasty as a salvage
operation for failed internal fixation of
trochanteric fractures in elderly patients. Acta
Orthop Belg. 2007, 73 (6), pp.729-36.
9. Kiran Kumar G.N et al. Bipolar
hemiarthroplasty in unstable intertrochanteric
fractures in elderly: A prospective study.
Journal of Clinical and Diagnostic Research.
2013, Vol. 7, No. 8, pp.1669-1671.
10. Sancheti K.H, Sancheti P.K, Shyam
A.K, Patil S, Dhariwal Q, Joshi R. Primary
hemiarthroplasty for unstable osteoporotic
intertrochanteric fractures in the elderly: A
retrospective case series. Indian J Orthop.
2010, Vol. 44, No. 4, pp.428-434.
Các file đính kèm theo tài liệu này:
- a_research_on_bone_mineral_density_in_the_hip_joint_and_eval.pdf